Is my quarter fixable? (pics)

if you cant find a good replacement, then it is fixable. personally, i would replace it. it is going to be alot of work to shrink the stretched out metal. only an experienced bodyman with lots of repair time under his belt will be able to PROPERLY fix that. someone could slap some filer over it and make it straight, but the metal really needs all the attention in this case. if the metal is not properly straightened, then the repair wont last very long. plus, most body guys cant straighten all the bodylines very well any way, so you might not be happy after it is repaired.

save yourself the headache and just replace it.

Ugh. Looks like you snapped a pic of one of my notch's rear quarters - both sides of mine kind of have that rippled Mustang cellulite look going on in their old age.

I'd have to agree that you could (or have someone) beat the snot out of it to form it back into shape and slap on a ton of Bondo, but it'd probably be cheaper/easier in the long run to just score a whole new piece and have it cut/welded on there. Bear in mind, though, that any time you go replacing entire body panels, you'd better be sure the guy doing the work is darn good at making everything fit straight and smoothed out, or you'll be no better off than you are, now ... and a few hundred dollars poorer, to boot.

The real question is:

Do you like Bondo?