I'll bet it's just your balancer. It probably slipped and now the marks are off but it's actually timed correctly, or close to it. It's sounds like you and I have the same problem. We both need to replace the balancer and front seal. I got a new balancer from NPD and it was just shy of $100.
If you do it yourself before I do let me know how it was and if there are any little tricks!
Good Luck!
If you do it yourself before I do let me know how it was and if there are any little tricks!
Good Luck!