I disagree with the claims of Twin Screw efficiency in comparison to a latest generation Eaton. Pulley both blowers for 6-8psi depending on which Eaton Blower it is and the Eaton will prove more efficient with lower discharge temps in comparison. Pulley them for 9-14psi and above and the KB stroll’s on by and keeps on walking and the Eaton turns into a hot air pump. I already covered the difference between the two types of blowers in detail and stated efficiency levels at particular boost levels for each in a previous thread, so rather than type it all out again, I'll link the thread to for everyone to read http://forums.stangnet.com/showthread.php?p=5334168#post5334168 (I think post #20 is about where I started to spew out information and #22 is where I compared their actual efficiency levles) and you can decide for yourself if you still believe that the Kenne Bell is far superior in all aspects.
I’d have to see the article and all of the parameters between the engines tested in the MM&FF comparison to make anything more than an speculated guess, but even without reading it, I’m sure the conditions in which the tests were conducted were carried in order to favor the Twin Screw, seeing as how it was a Kenne Bell sponsored comparison . When the two were tested at stock boost levels, were both cars pullied for 8psi, or were they just measured in comparison up to 8psi? A lot also can be contributed to manifold and runner design between the two. Not to mention the Eaton has also a size disadvantage (volume wise) with the M112 being only 1.84L per revolution in comparison to Kenne Bells 2.2L (or 2.3L if it was a Whipple) of air per revolution. Right off the bat the comparison is bias because of the Twin screws larger displacement and volume for air alone?
There's too many variables to provide a fair comparison between the two, which is why my judgement is reserved and I haven't been as quick to jump all over the Kenne Bell bandwagon as others have.
I’d have to see the article and all of the parameters between the engines tested in the MM&FF comparison to make anything more than an speculated guess, but even without reading it, I’m sure the conditions in which the tests were conducted were carried in order to favor the Twin Screw, seeing as how it was a Kenne Bell sponsored comparison
There's too many variables to provide a fair comparison between the two, which is why my judgement is reserved and I haven't been as quick to jump all over the Kenne Bell bandwagon as others have.
Gearbanger 101 said:I disagree with the claims of Twin Screw efficiency in comparison to a latest generation Eaton. Pulley both blowers for 6-8psi depending on which Eaton Blower it is and the Eaton will prove more efficient with lower discharge temps in comparison. Pulley them for 9-14psi and above and the KB stroll’s on by and keeps on walking and the Eaton turns into a hot air pump. I already covered the difference between the two types of blowers in detail and stated efficiency levels at particular boost levels for each in a previous thread, so rather than type it all out again, I'll link the thread to for everyone to read http://forums.stangnet.com/showthread.php?p=5334168#post5334168 (I think post #20 is about where I started to spew out information and #22 is where I compared their actual efficiency levles) and you can decide for yourself if you still believe that the Kenne Bell is far superior in all aspects.
I’d have to see the article and all of the parameters between the engines tested in the MM&FF comparison to make anything more than an speculated guess, but even without reading it, I’m sure the conditions in which the tests were conducted were carried in order to favor the Twin Screw, seeing as how it was a Kenne Bell sponsored comparison. When the two were tested at stock boost levels, were both cars pullied for 8psi, or were they just measured in comparison up to 8psi? A lot also can be contributed to manifold and runner design between the two. Not to mention the Eaton has also a size disadvantage (volume wise) with the M112 being only 1.84L per revolution in comparison to Kenne Bells 2.2L (or 2.3L if it was a Whipple) of air per revolution. Right off the bat the comparison is bias because of the Twin screws larger displacement and volume for air alone?
There's too many variables to provide a fair comparison between the two, which is why my judgement is reserved and I haven't been as quick to jump all over the Kenne Bell bandwagon as others have.
Interesting information.