to check vavle operation there are a few different procedures, 1 requires a decent (auto repair tech) scanner w/ OBDII control capability. 2 method, disconnect EGR valve, apply vacuum and watch for movement of the pintle inside the valve, if the valve pintle (inside the EGR Valve, not looking at the outside) moves, re-install. no movement replace valve. If it moves: With engine running @ idle, in park/neutral, apply vacuum to valve, engine RPMs should drop, possibly die. If it dies/RPMs drop, check the vacuum lines running to valve, and to the EGR sensor (called a DPFE sensor sometimes). Still no luck, take it to reputable shop.