Thanks Guys! I really appreciate it. hmmm decisions decisions... I hate this aha I think I'll probably end up going with #1 I just don't want to waste my money and not be happy with the final product :\
I've been thinking of re-doing my Rustoleum paintjob next spring with something along the lines of #1, except with the bottom half black and the top silver - hides the water spots I can't ever buff out of the black.
So, yeah ... another vote for #1. Almost has a sort of Starsky & Hutch 1976 Gran Torino kinda flair to it, except with black instead of white...