A PCV valve is a check valve of sorts. There's a secondary line that allows air back into the crankcase (and helps at WOT a little).
You can run into a situation with inadequate air ingress abilities or a vac leak/unmetered air situation with a butchered PCV system. If you have a blower (no sig), you might want to go to closed breathers.
I don't believe it will work that way. You could probably leave it open, but you run the risk of debris entering the engine via the opening. The reason I don't believe it would work is because it's a check valve, and it relies on the vacuum source from the intake to open the valve. If it were to suck oil up, then the valve would close when it floats on the oil, but otherwise, it would sit in a closed position without the vacuum.