Weird Vacuum

vristang said:
If the motor is healthy, and all is well your vac signal should be steady within about +/- 1".

I want to say that having a vac signal jump around at idle is an indication of the valves not sealing properly, but that is from memory and I don't trust my memory these days. I think this could cause vac fluctuations by allowing for revesion in the intake during compression/exhaust strokes.
Like I said though, that is from memory.

As an aside, remember that vac leaks do not only occur externally. Ram360 gives a good example. Also, I had a lower intake gasket slip down during assembly, which allowed for a vac leak common to the lifter valley. I had a very good vac signal, even before replacing the gasket. Only reason I found it was because I put the vac gauge on the outlet of the pcv. The moral of the story is that sometimes the starting fluid method of tracking down a vac leak is pretty useless.

ram360;
I had forgotten all about your vac problems. Glad to hear you got it sorted out:nice:
What other symptoms should I look for with a valve not seating correctly? Wouldn't it smoking? Sorry for all the questions but I am getting desperate at this point.
 
jh73 said:
What led me to start looking for a vacuum leak is that my car idles like crap almost as if it had a cam in it (I wish). It is also running very rich, burning the hell out of gas and when I rev up the motor the idle revs up fine but when it is coming back down it will stick at 1500 rpm for about 2 or 3 seconds and then slowly come back down to idle. I have already changed the IAC, TPS(98 volts), MAF, ACT, spark plugs & wires, Cap and Rotor, replaced 3 vacuum lines and tore apart my TB and EGR plate and cleaned it. At this point I am about to go crazy!:bang:


Mine does the same exact thing. I have 15in. of consistant vacuum except for last night, it was running like it had a HUGE cam (i do have an E303 cam but still lol) and it was barely idling, and while it was loping like crazy the vacuum was going from 8in. to 15in of vacuum. Today i disconnected the battery, hooked it back up, got it running to a nice idle, set tps to .98 volts and now it idles much better but still has that slight hesitation before it comes down to idle. I thought 15 in. of vacuum is kinda low especially since i dont have a huge cam in it or anything.
 
You took it to a shop, where a "technician" couldn't find out what the problem was? WTF. Ignition issue, I really doubt that. I didn't think about a stuck open EGR valve before but I don't think it would flux like that, it just would have a low vacuum reading. The needle bouncing like that tells me that the problem is at the cylinder head area. Bouncing vacuum is usually either valves not sealing, or uneven cylinders. Do the compression check and go from there. Maby pull the valve covers and run the motor (I know it's messy) and be sure the rocker arms are pushing down all the valves.
 
90mustangGT said:
You took it to a shop, where a "technician" couldn't find out what the problem was? WTF. Ignition issue, I really doubt that. I didn't think about a stuck open EGR valve before but I don't think it would flux like that, it just would have a low vacuum reading. The needle bouncing like that tells me that the problem is at the cylinder head area. Bouncing vacuum is usually either valves not sealing, or uneven cylinders. Do the compression check and go from there. Maby pull the valve covers and run the motor (I know it's messy) and be sure the rocker arms are pushing down all the valves.
What other symptoms should I look for with a valve not seating correctly? As far as performance goes the car runs great and pulls hard the problem is only at idle and now backfiring once or twice when the car is cold. Wouldn't it be smoking? Sorry for all the questions but I am getting desperate at this point.
 
Valve seals or valve guides being worn would cause oil to leak into the combustion chamber causing smoke. It would do this most under acceleration, if it were the rings it would smoke more under coasting or high vacuum situations.
 
Old school to the rescue, lol. My Reader's Digest Fix It Yourself manual from 1972 lol has the answer. "A fast, vibrating reading between 14 and 19 in.-Hg. indicates that the valve guides are worn. See a mechanic." It's kinda cool because, before EFI, engine analyzers and even breakerless ignition, all you had was simple tools like a vacuum gauge.
 
superhuaman said:
Old school to the rescue, lol. My Reader's Digest Fix It Yourself manual from 1972 lol has the answer. "A fast, vibrating reading between 14 and 19 in.-Hg. indicates that the valve guides are worn. See a mechanic." It's kinda cool because, before EFI, engine analyzers and even breakerless ignition, all you had was simple tools like a vacuum gauge.

Old School thanks for the info! How crucial is this to get fixed and is this causing the rest of my problems?
 
Well if you have worn valve guides, that will lead to worn valve seats and seals. So eventually you will have smoke on startup. I don't think that is the cause of your other problems though. I think worn valve guides would leak air/fuel mixture (intake guide) and exhaust (exhaust guide) into the crankcase. And cause it to run lean. You said yours seems to be rich. Well maybe the guides are worn bad enough to not pull in enough air. The fuel goes right in there b/c the injectors are right on top of the valves. Plus when there's an idle problem it usually is vacuum related. I would say it IS the valve guides for 100% sure, if you hadn't said the part about being rich.
 
Yeah, let me run this by you: The valve guides are worn, so when the piston sucks air/fuel into the cylinder, some of it is crankcase vapors instead of air. So it would be rich. And this is not being measured by the mass air flow sensor. I guess it depends on how bad your guides are. The needle is dropping whenever the valve(s) with the bad guide(s) operate(s). lol Most likely intake, but could be exhaust too.
:D
 
superhuaman said:
Yeah, let me run this by you: The valve guides are worn, so when the piston sucks air/fuel into the cylinder, some of it is crankcase vapors instead of air. So it would be rich. And this is not being measured by the mass air flow sensor. I guess it depends on how bad your guides are. The needle is dropping whenever the valve(s) with the bad guide(s) operate(s). lol Most likely intake, but could be exhaust too.
:D

Wow thinks for all the info! :hail2: At this point I'm just going to concern myself with the my idle problem and start saving for a new set of heads and maybe a cam (At least now it is somewhat justified as far as the wife is concerned :D) Do you have any suggestions as far as my idle goes?
 
Very well could be the valve guide, but I think it's more than that, it probally lead to misalignment of the valve. Well, now you need to figure out which guide(s) is/are bad. Chances are the rest of them are on the way out, and the valve and/or valve seat has been beat up, so a valve job might be in order. I am not a cylinder head rebuilder so I don't know if guides can be changed without pulling the head, I know you can for the springs and such, but don't know about the guides. Maby it's upgrade time!!!!
 
Well you've checked a lot of stuff. Since you're fine above idle, the only things it could be are IAC, EGR, timing, etc. I would like to think it's just the crappy vacuum. Like if you had low compression in your cylinders for example, your engine would run like crap b/c of low vacuum.