Cylinder Numbers... Easy question...

Yeah yeah, I just checked what I know how to check, NOT GOOD.

I pulled the TB and intake piping to get the the passenger side valve cover. Pulled it off, hoping to have a clear problem that I can fix. NOPE! Checked all the roller rockers, and valve springs. Everything was fine. None of the RR needed to be shimmed, the springs weren't broken, so my next conclusion is that something is wrong under the head. Valve hitting piston, or valve hitting cylinder wall. Either way, not good.

The heads are 351W heads, but they had worked fine w/o problems for years before now.

What should I check for next?
 
Did you pull the rockers and check the pushrods? With pedestal mount rockers and stock pushrods, they will usually bend first in light p to v contact. So you could have contact without anything showing up in the springs/rockers.

Cranking compression check? Have you pulled all the plugs to look for a problem cylinder?