Alright well I pulled the new starter out, had it checked, and its fine. Interestingly, the old starter was fine too. I checked the flywheel, and it seems to be fine (not missing any teeth or anything) So I got my money back for the new starter and now i'm stumped as to what to do. Before, when I tried to start the car, the starter would make horrible sounds (griding/popping) every once in a while, then finally start after I turned the key enough times. So whats wrong with it?