I'm not expecting them to out-do themselves; I just want them to stop sounding like something they're not. Right now,
these guys sound like a cover band trying desperately to capture the "old" Metallica's sound, but they're failing at it miserably, for the most part.
Man, all this talking about the bar, bar, bar, bar is making me want to GO TO a bar.
I'm not saying my review of it is how everyone else SHOULD or is GOING TO feel about it, it's just my take on it ... and I think it sucks. Really, Metallica should have released one of those three genuinely good tracks on their as their debut single for the album - THAT would REALLY motivate people to buy the thing. But "The Day That Never Comes" was only a halfway-good track ... actually, only like 1/3rd, maybe only 1/4th, because you have to suffer through 4 minutes of slow yodeling and ballad-like crap to get to the good part of that song.
FWIW, most of the mainstream garbage isn't even metal by even the loosest of definitions - it's frickin' emo garbage. Green Day and all that ... bleh. Not metal. Metallica ... ALMOST metal, now, I'll give them that. But still, not quite there, yet. The only way they can truly get back to their roots is to stop writing songs that are meant to be played on the radio, kill their frickin' sound engineer, and teach James to focus upon his guitar skills instead of singing.
Again, I can't say these guys aren't at least leaning in the right direction, but they've got a long ways to go. They're basically following on the heels of Megadeth ... who, by the way, isn't 100% quite yet, either, but they're a helluva lot farther along on the right track. I mean, I may not absolutely LOVE every track on Megadeth's latest album, but I can at least stand to listen to all of 'em - this new Metallica album only has 3, maybe 4 even worth a regular listen, IMO.