Oil plus is leaking help!

go get some orings at hardware store to seal the gap could use some silicone rvt type sealant around the oring AFTER TIGHTEND so as not to get any in the pan..not the best Idea though, the soft oring will work well like the ones supplied when you buy new panplug..hardware store or parts store will carry an assortment of orings, try to get a flat style if possible..and as you've learned do not over tighten the plugs...many of us have and it's a pain in the .ss.

on the part that bolts into the pan (that stays fixed always), i dont think putting sealant around just the very base of it (so as not to succept the oil in the sump to it), that would be ok. something like copper RTV or hylomar should work.

Dman's advice about rubber or nitrile washer/o-rings for the transient plug sound good to me.

BTW, if you end up re-tapping the hole, put grease on the tap - it should keep shavings attached to the grease rather than goin into the sump.

good luck.

I would go get another piggy back, used some good o-rings, and make sure you don't overtighten this time. At least if you get a new one you can be sure at least ONE of the plug will seal well.