just put my Roush in and I love it over stock, I haven't tried anything else but it is so easy to drive no missing gears and finding 3rd is so easy a girl could do it lol
The MGW is more expensive...but you'll know where you're extra money went. The shifter is excellent quality, and is fully adjustable to suit each driver. I have one, and love it...not to mention that I've never heard a single complaint about the shifter. Ever.