The dyno tests I've seen showed a gain of 8HP with the pulleys on one test, and 12HP with the other test. The gain increases with rpm - neither was more than 5HP until above 3500 rpm - so for most street driving you don't benefit much from them.
Some people suffer both charging issues and/or cooling issues. The underdrives also slow down the water pump and the mechanical fan. There's no way to tell if it will negatively impact yours without trying. Be careful about those that say "they worked on mine, they'll work on yours". There's simply not a one-size-fits-all when it comes to what's gonna happen when you put underdrives on. Obviously, the guy in Boondocks, Canada with the stock 5.0, no a/c, manual tranny and a brand new radiator is in a different situation than the guy in Houston, TX with auto/a-c and slugging through bumper to bumper traffic in August with a 14 year old stock radiator. You'll have to try it on yours and see. The good news is they're easy to sell used if they cause more problems than they solve.
I put the stockers back on mine to solve charging, cooling (summer with the a/c on) and power steering squealing issues.