99-04 smoked tailights

check partshopper, I saw a site that had them the other day and I'm thinking about buying them, I'm on my second set from APC and I'm completely dissatisfied with them. The seals turn yellow even after I ran a bead of silicone. So APC is s#!+ I sa another brand but they werent exactly stock looking, I didn't want that euro crap. They were called diamond or something like that. And they had smoked clear.
 
how do you think those would look on aftermarket clear tails? I couldnt find any smoked ones I like, so I put the ones I have on, but I hate the fake carbon fiber up close.