A smaller pulley will charge better, an larger one will load the engine less at the same rpm, and turn the alt slower at the same rpm.
I tried the underdrives on my 79 and it would not charge or run the ac at idle. Took them off the next day.
They work fine on my 82 to charge the battery and run the electric fan. In normal driving the 4.10 gears make up for the rpm the pulley lost and it does charge.
However, the bottle heater is still too much for my 82 style alternator at idle, so I try to be careful when I use it.