Basically, in stock form, the cross-sectional area of the shaft is "shadowed" by the blade because the blade is at an angle of approx. 2* to the flow. If it were perfectly parallel, we'd be having a totally different conversation where I'd be agreeing with you 100%. However, that blade can only open to that point.
Obviously, if you only increase the shaft size, it will start to emerge from this shadow, thus creating more restriction. Now, if you increase the blade diameter in equal ratios to the shaft, you're not changing the fact that it is still shadowed.
I think I've explained it pretty well.
No flame intended (anywhere in this thread for that matter), but I hope this isn't a case of "I spent alot of time and effort on this, and I'm not going to admit that it was all for nothing" type of thing.
We're all here to learn and share our knowledge. What we as individuals do with the information shared here is beyond anyone's control.
Like you state at the end of your last post, we're pretty much splitting frog hairs here, but the principles are valid.