Cold-Air intake vs. MAF system

sandman0023 said:
I have a 1989 GT and am stuck between a Cold-Air intake or a MAF system? Which one is better? :shrug:

You mean an aftermarket mass air sensor? Neither one is really going to do much on a stock engine. I say get a k/n panel filter, remove your air silencer, and save your money for something else down the road. If you really want one or the other get the cold air kit - sticking a bigger mas on a stock intake/tb/filter won't really accomplish anything.
 
actually. it'll accomplish somethin since the stock MAF is 58mm vs stock TB is 60mm so there is somesort of bottleneck there tho not much. I would get the 76mm kit and run a k&n with no silencer.
 
Get both.

The MAF will result in a bigger horsepower gain: the sensor itself will give you the biggest horsepower gain, rather than the larger tube size. The sensor is calibrated to give you a better, more accurate reading resulting in a superior air/fuel ratio in most performance MAFs. The difference between my 95 when it was running the stock MAF versus the Pro-M 75mm was amazing.

Get a Pro-M 75mm MAF and a $50 ebay cold air kit and you'll be good to go.
 
I should also add....

While the horsepower gains resulting from a cold air intake are negligible, it does significantly increase throttle response and adds a more aggressive sound to the motor- both factors in "fun" driving.
 
Swarzkopf said:
Get both.

The MAF will result in a bigger horsepower gain: the sensor itself will give you the biggest horsepower gain, rather than the larger tube size. The sensor is calibrated to give you a better, more accurate reading resulting in a superior air/fuel ratio in most performance MAFs. The difference between my 95 when it was running the stock MAF versus the Pro-M 75mm was amazing.

Get a Pro-M 75mm MAF and a $50 ebay cold air kit and you'll be good to go.

I'll say it again a bigger mas isn't going to do anything *noticable* for you. There's no bottleneck on a stock 89 intake system. Putting a bigger tube in between the filter and the tb may even make turbulence and degrade your performance. A Pro M or the like that comes with a calibrated sensor is great, but in order to burn more fuel you need more air. The stock mas tube isn't maxed out and putting a bigger tube there won't make it suck in more air! You'll end up running too rich. Put a 65mm tb on and then a bigger mas and you'll get a gain. Anyone who has dyno charts to prove a bigger mas on a BONE STOCK 89-93 5.0 makes any considerable amount of gain please post it I'd love to see it. If it makes more than ~5rwhp I'd be amazed.
As for the cold air, yes it'll increase throttle response a bit. You'll get the same effect by throwing in a k/n panel filter in your stock box and losing the air silencer. The only thing you don't get is the shiny chrome and the wind tunnel sound. These are both cool and the $50 ebay jobs are usually just as good as the brand namers.

Anyway, do some research before you buy anything. If you spend that money on gears instead you'll feel 10x the gain for about the same price.
 
I didn't mention that I put my Pro M 75mm mas on my car with the stock intake/tb and k/n conical. It felt *slower* afterward and ran WAY to rich. I put on the Performer and a 70mm tb and then I definately noticed a difference.
 
jb89coupe said:
You mean an aftermarket mass air sensor? Neither one is really going to do much on a stock engine. I say get a k/n panel filter, remove your air silencer, and save your money for something else down the road. If you really want one or the other get the cold air kit - sticking a bigger mas on a stock intake/tb/filter won't really accomplish anything.
i beg to differ a maf with adjustable FPR and the right injectors will make a noticable difference.....and a non show cold air will only help that much more.
 
In MM&SF Oct 2001 they did a dyno test on a 90 coupe before and after a c/l 76mm mass air AND inlet tube. The system made 9 peak hp @4800rmp and 10 peak ft/lbs @3000rmp. This type of gain is just bordering on what the butt dyno can pick up - and more importantly is it worth the $220+ for a first mod? BTW c/l claims a 3rwhp gain with just the inlet tube. Subtract that from the 9hp gain for the pair and the mass air tube ends up making ~6 or less peak hp by itself.
They also showed in that article that the stock airbox in with a k/n panel filter makes 2hp + 6ft/lbs more than an exposed underhood filter.
ProM claims "up to 12hp on a mildly modified 5.0" for their 75mm bullet. They don't mention what it does on a stocker.
So like I said to begin with, I wouldn't "waste" my money on a bigger mas for a first time mod, it's not worth it. It might take .05secs off your 1/4et - or you could drop $200 on gears and lose .4secs+ and make your car a whole lot more fun to drive.
Not trying to start an argument just trying to help the dude out. A mas is not a good bang for the buck purchase when you're all stock, bottom line.
 
sandman0023 said:
I didn't explain everything. I have an 89GT. I have ordered the BBK intake manifold and throttle body for it. Now, which would work better?

:D lol get a mass air sensor (not just a tube). Pro M tunes their meters for the air filter element (stock/conical/cold air), so you should decide what you want to do. If you can't afford a cold air kit along with the sensor then just throw in a k&n panel filter and dump your silencer. You can always send your meter back to be recalibrated later when/if you get a cold air kit. That stuff should wake your car up pretty noticably - let us know how the BBK works out and good luck.
 
Heres some dyno #'s from a completely stock 5.0 w/mods being 73mm MAF:

-----Stock MAF--------73mm C&L
-------HP---TQ--------HP---TQ

2500--116---244------116---244
3000--148---259------150---263
3500--173---259------177---265
4000--190---250------194---254
4500--194---226------200---233
5000--192---201------197---207
5500--169---161------176---168
 
In MM&SF Oct 2001 they did a dyno test on a 90 coupe before and after a c/l 76mm mass air AND inlet tube. The system made 9 peak hp @4800rmp and 10 peak ft/lbs @3000rmp. This type of gain is just bordering on what the butt dyno can pick up - and more importantly is it worth the $220+ for a first mod?

What kind of power gain do you expect from a $200 bolt on?
 
Swarzkopf said:
What kind of power gain do you expect from a $200 bolt on?

For ~$200 you can get a much more noticable gain than that. Hell you can boost your timing for free and get a gain of about the same. Did you see trickstang's post? 6 peak hp and 6 peak ft/lbs. You'd never notice that on the street and I'd hardly call that difference "amazing" like in your original post (then again you have a 95). But now we know the guy's got an intake/tb on the way and it should definately net him more than 6hp with that setup. :lock:
 
while getting a maf first wont do much, its definatly setting yourself up for future mods. if you have bigger maf and then do a TB and intake change the car will respond well to the mods.
 
what bbk intake did you get man.... is it the SSI?

if so post up some pics of that motha... i wouldnt spend the pricey money on it because of the numbers it puts out but ive always wanted to see one under the hood of a fox