I assume you were responding to my statement
I assume you were responding to my post . . .
let's say you've got two brake systems with equal stopping performance - let's say identical 13" disc brake systems, one manual and one power, same tire size, all else is equal, etc. Both systems have the same amount of potential stopping power when the pedal is pressed. Here's how I think they would behave differently, and how it feels to me on different cars I've driven:
1. The power brake system will be faster to engage and put a lot of stopping power in play quickly. This could be a bad thing, as you point out. (lock up brakes) The power brakes would keep pedal box flex from entering into it, and you wouldn't have to wait for your leg to build up the power.
2. The manual brake system would be easier to modulate in hard panic stops or in gradual increases of braking pressure, and might therefore be better in many cases.
3. All I'm saying, and would still say, is that the power brakes give you ultimately a faster initial engagement of the brakes - that's why we're all in danger of running into the idiots in new cars who slam on their new power ABS brakes HARD at the first sign of trouble . . .
I think we're in agreement, reading your first paragraph . . .
rebel65 said:
are you kidding me? you don't think you will push a soft pedal as much as a manual pedal in a short reaction time? why do you think people lock up brakes or get hit from behind all the time, because they slam on the brakes.
I have manual all discs, and it stops like a charm.just get a proportioning valve right and you will not be locking them up like those guys on the freeway.