Electric fans. Necessary?

TrickFlowd

Member
May 17, 2003
240
0
16
Sayre, PA
I currently have dual electric fans on my car from the previous owner. I plan to do a 3 core radiator in the next few months. I was wondering, can I just use a Flex-a-lite fan and run a shrowd? Rather than using the dual electrics? I don't really like the look of the electric fans, and if they go bad without notice, it could really do some damage. With my mods, are they necessary? :shrug:
 
As mentioned, dual fans have a lesser risk of you developing an overheating condition quickly enough that it's going to cause any damage before you notice something's wrong. Keep an eye on your temp gauge - and please, PLEASE, don't rely upon the stock gauge, it's terribly vague and inaccurate - and upgrade to a 3g alternator (if you don't have one, already), and you'll be fine.

If by the Flex-a-Lite fans you're referring to one of those clutchless flex-blade fans ... DON'T DOOOO EEEETT! :notnice: Unless you want to add a buttload of drag to your system (more so than the stock fan, because at least the stocker has a clutch to allow the fan to "slip" at higher RPM's), and want your car to sound like a friggin' dumptruck diesel's fan, plus the fact that you run the risk of experiencing some horrific flying debris damage if/when the thing comes apart at high RPM's ... I wouldn't recommend one, at all.

If you DO elect to go back to a mechanical fan, find someone that might wanna swap you for their stock fan blades/fan clutch/shroud assembly for your twin fans and relay(s). Also, verify that (if you're swapping in a plastic fan) the fan blades are not cracked, as they sometimes get from old age, heat, and so on.

You'll be trading down and losing around 5 to 7 hp in doing so, but if that's what you reeeeeeally want, the go for it. :shrug:
 
Ive been running a flex-alight fan on my car for the last 6 years!!! never had any troubles with it!!! no drag at all! if there is what would i pick up in running the 1/4 ? not much! and as for sounding like a diesel it doesnt have a sound to it at all it might if you don't have a shroud ? my car has run 11.90s and its never come apart!! i mean ya if it did you could have some damage! but i haven't seen one of these come apart! just my opinion and thoughts I'm sure others will have some to but i have never had any troubles with mine!!
 
Some have better luck than others with 'em. I just know what I've seen from others in the past, including one dude that had one of his flex-fan blades come loose and slice BOTH his upper and lower radiator hoses, AND mangle his serpentine belt. :shock: I've also seen a lot of radiators get destroyed by mechanical fans in general, even plastic ones, if the fan clutch decides to come apart or if the fan, itself, gives up the fight (and our plastic OEM fans are famous for cracking around the hub, anyway).

If an electric fan goes out ... so what? As long as you're keeping an eye on your temp gauge regularly, as you always should, the worst thing you might have to replace in the event that it craps out is a fan motor or a relay - no consequental, apocalyptic second-hand destruction of surrounding components.

If you're running 11's with a mechanical fan, guy, you're likely running high enough in RPM's that you DEFINITELY will benefit from switching to an electric fan. Destructive failure issues aside, an electric fan would not only cool just as well as (or better than) a flex fan, but again, you'll pick up a few horses from less parasitic drag, and your car will not sound like a Mack truck. :D

Also, if you look at the long-term issues of a mechanical fan, a bad fan clutch or otherwise imbalanced fan can beat the crap out of your water pump's bearings. But with an electrical fan? Fugeddaboutit. :nice:

Also, most e-fans allow more open space between your radiator and the front of your motor for things like, ohhhh, I dunno ... your hands, for whenever you want to work on something, perhaps? :D Or a supercharger, or piping for a turbo setup, depending on what kind of setup you use.

Additionally, when's the last time you've heard of someone getting their hand caught and mangled in an electrical fan on a Mustang? :shrug: Given, it helps not to be clumsy around a running motor, but when you're doing things like adjusting your timing and such, and you gotta reach right over that space to turn your dizzy ... all it takes is a loose sleeve, a droopy wristwatch, a wrench positioned wrong, a stray finger or two ... you get the idea. :)