normally when the motor mounts have gone south, the motor follows, literally. the fan will generally hit the BOTTOM of the shroud. yours hits the top. is everthing lined up perfectly with the radiator and all that? does the motor and trans tilt down in the rear?
i would still do the mounts, but check stuff out first. the motor is tilted up in the front now, no?
for what it is worth, the poly mounts keep the height about the same as stock mounts, whereas vert mounts should raise it up a little, which sounds like something you dont need. i have a vert, so i dont know about the first two, but when my fan started hitting the LOWER part of the shroud, new vert mounts raised the fan right back up to the middle of the fan oriface.
good luck.