Bang-for-buck wise, the GT-40p heads outflow the standard GT-40's on the exhaust side and have a smaller cc combustion chamber out of the box, so they'll make more power.
If you're gonna go with ported heads, get whatever you can cheaper. I'd personally go standard GT-40's in that case to make header selection easier, plus to get all you can out of porting you want the bigger exhaust valve you already have in that case, the P head outflows on the exhaust due to port shape more than size. That goes out the window somewhat with a good port job.
If you're thinking X's or Y's, I'd just get AFR 165's, you'd have to spend a small fortune on a port job for X's to keep up with AFR's.