I don't know about this situation. But some tachs could be calibrated differently then others. What I mean is, say if you run an aftermarket tach directly off the wire feeding into your stock tach (by the gauges). It might be getting the same reading but the aftermarket one may be calibrated differently. I heard it's a better idea to tap into the wire running into your computer or off the coil. I heard that doing it by the cluster wont' be a precise enough time. Which is maybee why some people experience a different rpm range? I run a shiftlight in my car but I tapped the wire directly off the coil and back into my car. My shiftlight is extremely accurate with my tach. I dunno