• Mustang Forums
  • 2005 - 2014 S-197 Mustang -General/Talk-
  • 2010 - 2014 Specific Tech

new 5.0 auto vs. stick

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deths91Gt
  • Start date Start date Nov 15, 2011

Deths91Gt

Founding Member
Sep 30, 1998
1,394
3
39
KS
Nov 15, 2011
#1
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #1
I'm thinking of getting the new 5.0 but wanted to get some opinions on stick or auto performance wise. I had a auto car in the days of the foxbodies with the AOD. And those in stock form sucked. I had a 06 GT auto and it was much better but i missed rowing thru the gears. Hows the new 6 speed auto compare to the stick in 1/4 mile times?
 

LAVAgt2012

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2011
1,098
28
58
Panama City, FL
Nov 15, 2011
#2
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #2
I bought the manual, test drove both. It all depends on what you like or used to. The auto in the car is pretty beast, and unless you get a tune that skip shift can be annoying at times (until you get used to it, then it isn't too bad). Myself I love my stick, but unlike the older cars it really doesn't matter for performance I think they are pretty equally matched.
 

Minion56

New Member
Nov 15, 2011
7
0
1
Scarborough, Maine
Nov 15, 2011
#3
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #3
I was hung up on the auto because I'm more of a commuter than going to the drag strip...but my friends are really convincing me to go manual. I test drove both...both are awesome. But the manual has its plus side. Dropping it into a low gear to fly past someone on the highway...reving the engine at a stop light...over all more control. I'm in the market for a 2011 or better GT and I'm going with the manual now....its just too much fun.
Just my opinion.
 
S

ssaulnier

New Member
Sep 26, 2011
1
0
1
Nov 15, 2011
#4
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #4
2013 Mustang SelectShift Auto Tranny

Ford just announced that the 2013 Mustang will be available with a SelectShift automatic transmission. Also the automatic version will now be available with the optional Brembo brake package. I know what I am buying in Spring 2012. See link below.

2013 Mustang
 
S

stevenstarke

New Member
Nov 2, 2011
14
0
1
Nov 15, 2011
#5
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #5
get the stick, auto is weak
 

MoshpitMad

Active Member
Oct 26, 2011
130
5
28
Albany, NY
Nov 15, 2011
#6
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #6
I've been a stick guy vs auto guy since I learned at the fresh age of 25...I love the control at all times.
 
T

thelastsumurai

New Member
Feb 24, 2011
20
0
1
Nov 15, 2011
#7
  • Nov 15, 2011
  • #7
First auto in many years.. This auto is great. Ran 12.9 this Saturday at Gainesville Raceway, FL Stone stock. tires and all
 

LAVAgt2012

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2011
1,098
28
58
Panama City, FL
Nov 16, 2011
#8
  • Nov 16, 2011
  • #8
stevenstarke said:
get the stick, auto is weak
Click to expand...

 

Jim Vaccaro

Founding Member
Jan 28, 2000
1,104
0
36
Brooklyn
Nov 17, 2011
#9
  • Nov 17, 2011
  • #9
Before you buy the Manual, check out the new features comming on the 2013 Auto,,Ford is getting closer and closer to a Combo of manual and auto in one and the same tranny..
 
C

CobraGT87

Mr. Speed Density
Founding Member
Apr 22, 1999
1,876
0
36
USA
Nov 18, 2011
#10
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #10
I've been a stick man all my life, I just brought home my new 2012 GT/CS in a Manual. I must say I sure like the gear spacing they used esp for a 3.55 rear gear. I say stick if for no other reason engine rpm control. I had a few stab & steer stangs and while great for reaction time, I found myself bored with nothing to do. LOL.
 
D

danond

Member
Jun 20, 2011
36
0
7
Nov 18, 2011
#11
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #11
No matter what they do with that 2013 auto, it won't have a clutch. Still an auto.

--
Dan in ND
 

LAVAgt2012

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2011
1,098
28
58
Panama City, FL
Nov 18, 2011
#12
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #12
Jim Vaccaro said:
Before you buy the Manual, check out the new features comming on the 2013 Auto,,Ford is getting closer and closer to a Combo of manual and auto in one and the same tranny..
Click to expand...

+1

yeah that new select shift would be a nice feature. I have that in my suv, i can be in drive, or i can go over to the other side and have it in kind of an auto manual and use paddle shifters. It would be kind of need if they adopted that idea, not saying the paddle shifts just where you pick what mode your car is in.
 

MightyMike16

New Member
Oct 30, 2011
7
0
1
Long Island NY
Nov 18, 2011
#13
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #13
My 2011 is a stick. I wasnt about to pass that up. I never drove stick prior to this either... Funny ****... for a car guy.
 

'13_ImpactBlue_GT

Angry Little Elf
Mar 30, 2005
872
2
98
Where the men are men and the sheep are nervous
Nov 18, 2011
#14
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #14
LAVAgt2012 said:
+1

yeah that new select shift would be a nice feature. I have that in my suv, i can be in drive, or i can go over to the other side and have it in kind of an auto manual and use paddle shifters. It would be kind of need if they adopted that idea, not saying the paddle shifts just where you pick what mode your car is in.
Click to expand...

Just curious.....how much torque can the 6 speed auto's handle before they fail?
 
A

acrbill

New Member
Jun 1, 2005
11
0
1
Nov 18, 2011
#15
  • Nov 18, 2011
  • #15
I bought a manual 2011 last year. It was a job 1 car and had all sorts of clutch issues. When it worked it worked great. Unfortunately I ended up getting fed up with its issues and recently traded for an auto car.
The auto is very stout. With a tune it chirps the 2-3 shift hard. You definitely are disconnected from the driving experience though.
 
J

jmoorets

New Member
Mar 27, 2011
9
2
1
WV
Nov 19, 2011
#16
  • Nov 19, 2011
  • #16
Pick what you like

I've driven both over the years. Pick what YOU like (not what somebody else likes).

For me and my '12 5.0, it was stick. It's fun to drive. I feel more engaged as a driver with the car. And the Mustang is a "driver's" car. I like choosing when to downshift (and hearing the burble and pop through the FRPP sport mufflers) and then powering out of a tight hairpin.

But, again, you should pick what you like.
 

Juice2012

Member
Sep 9, 2011
85
4
8
Nov 19, 2011
#17
  • Nov 19, 2011
  • #17
As far as I know you can't change the rear end from the factory with the auto (3.15 gears). The manual has steeper gears, with the option of going up to the 3.73. So, stock for stock from the factory, the manual is faster.
 

Coyote5.0

5 Year Member
Aug 27, 2010
625
102
64
Portage, Wisconsin
Nov 20, 2011
#18
  • Nov 20, 2011
  • #18
1/4 mile times will depend on the driver. For the average driver, the automatic will probably be slightly faster and more consistent.

If you are looking for the best daily driver or a good driver's car, get the manual. For normal driving on the streets, the autos are programmed for fuel efficiency, and tend to want to go into the highest gear as soon as possible, and stay there as long as possible. With the manual, you are in control, and more connected with the car.

The new 6-speed manual is also much smoother and more refined than the 5-speed manual from the 05-09, which having driven one after getting used to a 2011, felt rather clunky and truck-like in comparison.
 

Juice2012

Member
Sep 9, 2011
85
4
8
Nov 20, 2011
#19
  • Nov 20, 2011
  • #19
Coyote5.0 said:
1/4 mile times will depend on the driver. For the average driver, the automatic will probably be slightly faster and more consistent.

If you are looking for the best daily driver or a good driver's car, get the manual. For normal driving on the streets, the autos are programmed for fuel efficiency, and tend to want to go into the highest gear as soon as possible, and stay there as long as possible. With the manual, you are in control, and more connected with the car.

The new 6-speed manual is also much smoother and more refined than the 5-speed manual from the 05-09, which having driven one after getting used to a 2011, felt rather clunky and truck-like in comparison.
Click to expand...

True. Maybe I should rephrase that. If you don't suck, the manual will be faster from the factory.
 
B

Burns331

Member
Jun 12, 2010
107
0
16
Nov 20, 2011
#20
  • Nov 20, 2011
  • #20
Juice2012 said:
As far as I know you can't change the rear end from the factory with the auto (3.15 gears). The manual has steeper gears, with the option of going up to the 3.73. So, stock for stock from the factory, the manual is faster.
Click to expand...


The auto has deeper gears in the transmission.

The auto with 3.15 has a lower overall gear ratio than the manual with 3.73's.

The manual is not faster from this stand point.

The driver mod will define the difference between an auto winning and a manual winning every time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
Electrical HELP! 1989 5.0 Stick, Voltage Bleed onto Ignition Trigger wire
  • ChickenDeluxe
  • May 14, 2026
  • Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech
Replies
7
Views
162
Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech May 24, 2026
ChickenDeluxe
C
Engine Suggestions on an engine rebuild. Stock cam/GT40Ps or aftermarket on both for a fun weekend driver?
  • MadSquirrelTech
  • Apr 28, 2026
  • Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech
  • 2
Replies
23
Views
614
Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech May 7, 2026
MadSquirrelTech
New Member with a 1992
  • Clutchfork
  • Oct 18, 2025
  • The Welcome Wagon
Replies
5
Views
265
The Welcome Wagon Oct 19, 2025
Clutchfork
B
water pump installation questions
  • B0udreaux
  • Feb 5, 2026
  • 1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk-
  • 2
Replies
38
Views
1K
1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk- Feb 28, 2026
General karthief
Progress Thread The Mach Returns - Update/build thread
  • squeak93
  • Feb 20, 2026
  • 1996 - 2004 SN95 Mustang -General/Talk-
Replies
5
Views
266
1996 - 2004 SN95 Mustang -General/Talk- Jun 1, 2026
squeak93
Share:
Bluesky Email Share Link
  • Mustang Forums
  • 2005 - 2014 S-197 Mustang -General/Talk-
  • 2010 - 2014 Specific Tech
Menu
Log in

Register

  • Forums
  • What's new
  • Media
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Sponsor
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?