The Great Debate

Which is the better power adder?


  • Total voters
    25
  • Poll closed .

tannerc91gt

This last 25% is foreign territory at this point
Founding Member
Nov 29, 1999
4,392
2,967
234
Indiana
So my last thread pretty much turned into a debate on power adders and has got me thinking. I've got my own opinions but im interested in hearing from both sides. I realize this is opening a can of worms :D
I'd like to see the Pros and Cons of each in terms of tunability, reliability, power, maintenance, etc.

So lets hear it....
 
It's a matter of personal preference. As mentioned earlier, turbochargers are "free" power in that it does not "cost" your motor anything to spin the turbo. Belt driven superchargers are parasitic in that they rob horsepower by their very nature by putting parasitic drag on the crankshaft of the motor. That said, I own a supercharged vehicle, and I can tell you from experience that having instantaneous, neck-snapping torque on demand is insanely fun on the street. However, if I built this car rather than buying it, it would have a turbo on it. If it were a turbo car it would also probably be on the jackstands instead of me out terrorizing the streets with it, so take that into consideration as well. That's my .02
 
It's a matter of personal preference. As mentioned earlier, turbochargers are "free" power in that it does not "cost" your motor anything to spin the turbo. Belt driven superchargers are parasitic in that they rob horsepower by their very nature by putting parasitic drag on the crankshaft of the motor. That said, I own a supercharged vehicle, and I can tell you from experience that having instantaneous, neck-snapping torque on demand is insanely fun on the street. However, if I built this car rather than buying it, it would have a turbo on it. If it were a turbo car it would also probably be on the jackstands instead of me out terrorizing the streets with it, so take that into consideration as well. That's my .02

:stupid:
It's all up to the build of your engine is you're gonna do a stock block turbos will make more power safer, drivability wont suffer, dont get me wrong my truck is grat, when the boost kicks in it makes my face do this weird thing like a smile, but if you're gonna go balls out on a 408 or something then either is up to you, if its gonna be an all out drag car i say turbos, if you wanna build a road course car, then i say supercharger, if you wanna build a fun street car you cant go wrong with either
 
My vote goes to coffee, it's free where i work, somewhat reliable depending on how many coworkers are tired, or just dragging a bit. The power is ok, I'm always looking for more power. Maintenance isn't bad...usually one cup/hr, 3 cups during the entire day. And tunability....well that took a while to get the ratio right...but seems like 12oz coffee/ 2 creams/ 3 sugars/ and I'm running lean and mean!!!!

On a serious note...My vote is cubic inches
 
Turbo all the way, there is a reason that all the fast outlaw and, 275 guys are using em.

Anyone that says supercharger has never been for a ride in a built turbo car.

Yes we will get the great pissing match of my roots makes tq right off idle, yea thats great, but it falls off at 5000, To each his own i guess.

I'll say this, and people will disagree, but they are wrong. a properly sized turbo will make more peak hp and TQ at the same boost level versus a smiliarly sized blower. Trbofox is a perfect example, he has a hellion kit with a 62mm turbo, relativly small, comparable to an s-trim, making 511 rwhp. 622 ft.lbs. torque @10psi
 
Turbo all the way, there is a reason that all the fast outlaw and, 275 guys are using em.

correct... funny how all of the fastest outlaw cars are turbo's and they all have one other thing in common... PETTY/PROLINE combos!

also funny how a turbo 275 car came and busted john urists ass in SSO..
 
Its all in your plans for the car. Turbos are the most effective and efficient way to make power, but the systems are more complex and require more planning than just bolting on a non-intercooled centri.

I'll say this, and people will disagree, but they are wrong. a properly sized turbo will make more peak hp and TQ at the same boost level versus a smiliarly sized blower. Trbofox is a perfect example, he has a hellion kit with a 62mm turbo, relativly small, comparable to an s-trim, making 511 rwhp. 622 ft.lbs. torque @10psi

+1
 
charger all the way for a fun street car. if your looking for balls to the wall horsepower and your not concerned about cost/complexness then do a turbo. street cars are made in low mph low rpm situations (starting out) in my book. power when i want it is a win for me.
 
Ok just to clarify a bit, consider the power adder would be going on a relatively mild 302.I'm not attempting to building a 10.5 outlaw car or a 408 or anything like that, just a stock bottom end with stock heads. Also consider the vehicle to see about 75/25 street/strip time.
Looking to hear from those of you with either power adder that sees quite a bit of street use. To me, the drawback with the turbo cars is the amount of time they spend not being drivable, i could be incorrect but it seems like theres a lot more maintenance down time with a turbo set up.
 
again its how complex you want it to be. turbos take longer to setup and such but if you dont want any power being added until you rev it high enough then a turbo is what you want. a turbo street car you can have it be the same as stock pretty much until you rev it high enough then it makes boost. a charged car will make power from a launch and in lower rpms much better.
 
My vote goes to coffee, it's free where i work, somewhat reliable depending on how many coworkers are tired, or just dragging a bit. The power is ok, I'm always looking for more power. Maintenance isn't bad...usually one cup/hr, 3 cups during the entire day. And tunability....well that took a while to get the ratio right...but seems like 12oz coffee/ 2 creams/ 3 sugars/ and I'm running lean and mean!!!!

On a serious note...My vote is cubic inches

this could possily be the MOST unhelpful response ever.




I definitly laughed though :nice:
 
My vote goes to coffee, it's free where i work, somewhat reliable depending on how many coworkers are tired, or just dragging a bit. The power is ok, I'm always looking for more power. Maintenance isn't bad...usually one cup/hr, 3 cups during the entire day. And tunability....well that took a while to get the ratio right...but seems like 12oz coffee/ 2 creams/ 3 sugars/ and I'm running lean and mean!!!!

On a serious note...My vote is cubic inches
:rlaugh::rlaugh::lol::lol::rlaugh::rlaugh::stupid:
 
My vote goes to coffee, it's free where i work, somewhat reliable depending on how many coworkers are tired, or just dragging a bit. The power is ok, I'm always looking for more power. Maintenance isn't bad...usually one cup/hr, 3 cups during the entire day. And tunability....well that took a while to get the ratio right...but seems like 12oz coffee/ 2 creams/ 3 sugars/ and I'm running lean and mean!!!!

I go with black and 4 sugars or however much it take to taset good, we have free gogo juice here too, but when people are really feeling a kick in the pants we've got liquid NAWZ(expresso machine), if your part of the club its like 12 bucks every 3 months and will get you pupils nice and dialated.

After work, i usually hit the pump for racegas(jack&redbull), now that stuff will get you moving
 
Ok just to clarify a bit, consider the power adder would be going on a relatively mild 302.I'm not attempting to building a 10.5 outlaw car or a 408 or anything like that, just a stock bottom end with stock heads. Also consider the vehicle to see about 75/25 street/strip time.
Looking to hear from those of you with either power adder that sees quite a bit of street use. To me, the drawback with the turbo cars is the amount of time they spend not being drivable, i could be incorrect but it seems like theres a lot more maintenance down time with a turbo set up.

Alright i'll weigh in, i dont have a turbo gas vehicle but i do have a turbo diesel, so keep that in mind, and the engine is a 444 not something tiny so redline is only set at 3300rpms but as far as the street goes its fun when the boost kicks in, but those few seconds when you're waiting for it to hit is dreadful, now my truck isnt as fast as it could be or probably should be if i wasnt scared to blow my tranny but i have still got a best of 13.98, but as far as my fox goes, its getting a supercharger, but thats cause it will see alot of road course duty and rarely any street time, hope some of that helps