This one was here before all the others, why would this one be locked?
No need for separate threads for every game, its retarded.
so Manning is better b/c why?
He has more career passing yards....big deal
How many Playoff games has Brady played in and lost compared to Manning? Its not just the QB that is responsible for winning a game and it was not just them that won or lost those games but the QB takes the brunt of responsibility when they do lose in most cases.
IMO there is nothing that can be said about Peyton Manning that makes him stand out as being better then Tom Brady.
Actually this thread is for the regular season,, and since the regular season is OVER its retarted to keep it and it should be locked... Seperate threads for playoffs SHOULD be made since the playoffs are special...
/thread
No way talk about a small world!!! Class of '01 Toms River East here.. along with the guy below me
Thats pretty sweet, you probably see all kinds of stuff being loaded into planes!
we've been outa school for a long time buddy... Still have scars when you burnt my arm by doing the one wheel peel in the buick in the senior lot
I dont really think one is better than the other, but Brady isnt a better QB than Manning imo. I think you are not giving the situation Brady was placed in enough credit. I dont think anyone can argue that Brady isnt great, but if he played with Atlanta or Oakland he wouldnt be considered one of the elite of all time. Manning did come into an awful team and took them in his second year to 13-3 and a playoff birth. He did that with Jim Mora as coach and a horrible defense.
Brady has had the best coach in the history of the NFL his whole career, if you dont think that has anything to do with Bradys career playoff record you are crazy. God I just wish the Colts had a coach as good as him, Dungy is a great man but has so under achieved with the talent he has had.
But on a personal note, I was embarrased when the Colts fans booed the girl. It was pathetic and disgraceful. But if you dont think every team has its dumb fans then you are crazy. At least it wasnt Philly or they would have thrown batteries at her.
This is the point I was making.
You cant say one is better than the other b/c of the different situations. Yep, Brady is an outdoor QB, credit him. Manning has no where near the number of skilled receivers & great coaches, credit him.
Both are outstanding and are the best in the NFL right now. Why not leave it at that?