• Mustang Forums
  • 1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk-
  • Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech

Windage tray HP diffrences

  • Thread starter Thread starter 352Ford2
  • Start date Start date Feb 23, 2006
  • 1
  • 2
Next
1 of 2 Next Last

352Ford2

New Member
Oct 12, 2005
393
0
0
Seattle,WA
Feb 23, 2006
#1
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #1
A while back I was reading about windage trays and this mag (I think it was pop hotroding) did some dyno tests proving that mesh windage trays make more power than the louvered ones. My theory has always been that the louvered ones were better because they kept the oil outside the tray off the crank better, but these guys were thinking that the droplets inside the tray on the louvered one were bouncing back off of the tray onto the crank and that the mesh kept that at bay.

Thoughts anyone, other dyno tests, etc?
 

srothfuss

Last night I stabbed the same guy 7 times in a row
Oct 17, 2004
1,796
3
0
Woodward Ave.
Feb 23, 2006
#2
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #2
No actual data or proof, just theory: I tend to agree with you because the whole purpose of the windage tray is to keep the oil away from the crank throws. As the Revolutions of the crank increase, the amount of power that each counter weight needs to get past the oil also increases. I have heard it's anywhere from a 10 to 20 horsepower increase depending on what direction the wind is blowing that particular day.

Sneaky power / Free power = cool!

The only way the mesh one could work is when the mesh is so thin that the surface tension of the oil is too great to pass through the openings in the metal
 

352Ford2

New Member
Oct 12, 2005
393
0
0
Seattle,WA
Feb 23, 2006
#3
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #3
srothfuss said:
The only way the mesh one could work is when the mesh is so thin that the surface tension of the oil is too great to pass through the openings in the metal
Click to expand...

exactly
 
8

89white50

Member
Nov 16, 2004
440
1
18
central MA
Feb 23, 2006
#4
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #4
well in the crank case, its pretty much a thickass oil cloud at descent to high rpms. I would say the difference between the 2 are negliable in a street motor. i could see a high horse drag motor. BUt seriously, if you're that worried just have the crank throws knife edged.
 
8

86bluecobra

Advanced Member
Dec 20, 2004
4,265
12
69
B.C. Canada
Feb 23, 2006
#5
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #5
i have seen many a dyno test that actually proves 6 rwhp to 10 rwhp in mags with just a windage tray addition. I would say the difference between the louvered and mesh trays are not much. Just one company with the patent on 1 way to build em claiming more hp then the other guys patent.
 
S

seijirou

Founding Member
Aug 15, 2002
2,417
4
48
DFW
Feb 23, 2006
#6
  • Feb 23, 2006
  • #6
You know. Aerodynamically it would make more sense to knife-edge the trailing edge of the counterweights rather than the leading edge.

Just a random thought.
 

352Ford2

New Member
Oct 12, 2005
393
0
0
Seattle,WA
Feb 24, 2006
#7
  • Feb 24, 2006
  • #7
seijirou said:
You know. Aerodynamically it would make more sense to knife-edge the trailing edge of the counterweights rather than the leading edge.

Just a random thought.
Click to expand...


yes and that is why I have always thought that people that knife edge cranks (they always do the front side) never passed aerodynamics 101
 
S

Sicarius428

Active Member
Jan 6, 2004
2,085
5
49
Feb 24, 2006
#8
  • Feb 24, 2006
  • #8
The knife edge on the front helps deflect the impact of the crank hitting the oil i think. For sustained movement through the oil... yeah the trailing edge might be better but its the difference of chopping through the oil rather than pushing.
Kevin
 

352Ford2

New Member
Oct 12, 2005
393
0
0
Seattle,WA
Feb 24, 2006
#9
  • Feb 24, 2006
  • #9
Sicarius428 said:
The knife edge on the front helps deflect the impact of the crank hitting the oil i think. For sustained movement through the oil... yeah the trailing edge might be better but its the difference of chopping through the oil rather than pushing.
Kevin
Click to expand...

movement through any fluid (yes air is a fluid in fluid mechanics) the back side is always more important than the front, but you really shouldn't look at it that way, its a system. the changes you make upstream affect downstream.


end result :knife edjing the front does esentaly nothing
 

ninety15.0

New Member
Mar 10, 2004
1,336
0
0
Feb 24, 2006
#10
  • Feb 24, 2006
  • #10
i think you guys may need to read up on your fluid mechanics...b/c the frontal cross sectional area also has a dramatic effect on resistance. Reducing the effective frontal area does indeed increase efficiency. Think of a corvette compared to a fox body...the frontal area is much smaller on the corvette making it slice through the air much better. Or look at a porsche, small in the front and tappered/curved in the rear...the best design! I do however agree w/ you that knifedging the trailin edge may also improve performance. Something someone should try and dyno test for results.
 
S

seijirou

Founding Member
Aug 15, 2002
2,417
4
48
DFW
Feb 25, 2006
#11
  • Feb 25, 2006
  • #11
There is a common misconsception about drag coefficient. It's counter-intuitive. Yes having a pointy front does help you "slice" through the medium in which you travel. People think that slicing through air must be so much better than pushing through air because they assume it must be similar to cutting through a solid, where sharp is key. However, especially with air, the energy required to push a blunt frontal cross-section through is a drop in the bucket compared to the energy required to overcome the vacuum generated by a blunt rear cross-section. That Porsche will actually have less aerodynamic drag going in reverse than it has going forward. If you really want to see automobiles designed to be as aerodynamic as possible, find some pictures of solar powered vehicles. You'll see many are teardrop shaped, blunt side forward.

Through air, the benifit of a pointy front is neglegable untill you approach sonic velocity.
 

352Ford2

New Member
Oct 12, 2005
393
0
0
Seattle,WA
Feb 27, 2006
#12
  • Feb 27, 2006
  • #12
seijirou said:
There is a common misconsception about drag coefficient. It's counter-intuitive. Yes having a pointy front does help you "slice" through the medium in which you travel. People think that slicing through air must be so much better than pushing through air because they assume it must be similar to cutting through a solid, where sharp is key. However, especially with air, the energy required to push a blunt frontal cross-section through is a drop in the bucket compared to the energy required to overcome the vacuum generated by a blunt rear cross-section. That Porsche will actually have less aerodynamic drag going in reverse than it has going forward. If you really want to see automobiles designed to be as aerodynamic as possible, find some pictures of solar powered vehicles. You'll see many are teardrop shaped, blunt side forward.

Through air, the benifit of a pointy front is neglegable untill you approach sonic velocity.
Click to expand...



right on the money, glad to see I am not the only one who passed engineering 101
 

1991vert

10 Year Member
Feb 27, 2004
1,103
7
69
Ludlow, MA
Feb 28, 2006
#13
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #13
cliff notes for those who have no idea what you're talking about?

instead of it being squared, make it into a crescent shape?
 

srothfuss

Last night I stabbed the same guy 7 times in a row
Oct 17, 2004
1,796
3
0
Woodward Ave.
Feb 28, 2006
#14
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #14
I passed engineering.... The front of the crank throws should be rounded not 100% square, then the back should taper off to a point or wedge. Just to clarify

Like the shape of a wing. Are we talking about flight or windage trays still?
 
S

seijirou

Founding Member
Aug 15, 2002
2,417
4
48
DFW
Feb 28, 2006
#15
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #15
srothfuss said:
I passed engineering.... The front of the crank throws should be rounded not 100% square, then the back should taper off to a point or wedge. Just to clarify

Like the shape of a wing. Are we talking about flight or windage trays still?
Click to expand...

Almost like a wing, but not 100%. Remember a wing has a curved upper surface with a flat lower surface to create lift. You wouldn't want to have a crank throw creating horizonal lift and trying to walk the crank forwards or backwards now would you
 

ninety15.0

New Member
Mar 10, 2004
1,336
0
0
Feb 28, 2006
#16
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #16
I passed engineering aswell...and srothfuss is right...the best combination would be a rounded front and a tappered trailing edge. its pretty simple if you still dont believe that reducing frontal area helps reduce drag...look at everything designed for aero and you will find a tendency to have the smallest actualy leading edge area. I understand that solar cars are tear drop shaped...but you have to realize the front of those cars still come to a small rounded point in the front....a crank counterweight will follow the same laws of dynamics and fluids plain and simple. Also you would never design a counterweight like a wing...i dont think that what anyone was implying.
 

cleanLX

Founding Member
Jan 17, 2001
976
537
144
Feb 28, 2006
#17
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #17
the crank is pushing thru suspended oil.
boats have pointed bows.
solar cars don't drive thru suspended oil at insane speeds.
 
8

89white50

Member
Nov 16, 2004
440
1
18
central MA
Feb 28, 2006
#18
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #18
id let the 5rwhp go and keep the structural integrity of the crank personally, over making my throws into teardrop shapes...lol. oh and i also passed engineering 101.
 
8

89white50

Member
Nov 16, 2004
440
1
18
central MA
Feb 28, 2006
#19
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #19
the crank is pushing thru suspended oil.
boats have pointed bows.
solar cars don't drive thru suspended oil at insane speeds.
Click to expand...

thats exactly what i said before, just a little better.
 

srothfuss

Last night I stabbed the same guy 7 times in a row
Oct 17, 2004
1,796
3
0
Woodward Ave.
Feb 28, 2006
#20
  • Feb 28, 2006
  • #20
Too bad my engineering path lead me to injection molding interior parts and trim pieces. Not that I don't like my job, but it isn't the coolest part of automobiles these days.


And of course, I didn't mean that we want the crank to be rocking back and forth with a wing shaped throw. But let us just think that if we had two identical wing shaped (each oppisite of each other) wouldn't any lift generated by said two crank throws be canceled out? Would that also prevent movement of the crank for aft? Or does the constant change in fluid ruin this topic?
 
  • 1
  • 2
Next
1 of 2 Next Last
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
'03 GT Fuel Pump/Pressure/Delivery Issue
  • Brodach
  • Oct 21, 2025
  • SN95 4.6L Mustang Tech
Replies
8
Views
1K
SN95 4.6L Mustang Tech Oct 31, 2025
gkomo
M
Progress Thread mnky99 2001 V6 evap core, ac compressor, heater core replacement
  • mnky99
  • Sep 5, 2025
  • 1996 - 2004 SN95 Mustang -General/Talk-
Replies
1
Views
750
1996 - 2004 SN95 Mustang -General/Talk- Sep 5, 2025
mnky99
M
Place to Avoid: Jamison Auto Group in Gulfport, MS
  • D Durden
  • Oct 20, 2025
  • 1965 - 1973 Classic Mustangs -General/Talk-
  • 2 3
Replies
46
Views
4K
1965 - 1973 Classic Mustangs -General/Talk- Jul 16, 2026
Noobz347
4.6 question for those in the know....
  • LILCBRA
  • Aug 30, 2024
  • 2005 - 2014 S-197 Mustang -General/Talk-
Replies
15
Views
2K
2005 - 2014 S-197 Mustang -General/Talk- Sep 4, 2024
Adieu
Progress Thread Komo's 1990 GT - Parts Gathering Purgatory & Home Remodel
  • gkomo
  • Sep 23, 2024
  • 1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk-
  • 104 105 106
Replies
2K
Views
92K
1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk- Nov 9, 2026
gkomo
Share:
Bluesky Email Share Link
  • Mustang Forums
  • 1979 - 1995 (Fox, SN95.0, & 2.3L) -General/Talk-
  • Fox 5.0 Mustang Tech
Menu
Log in

Register

  • Forums
  • What's new
  • Media
  • Resources
  • Contact
  • Sponsor
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?