T5 Whine 1st-3rd

Turkey Sammich

I can't fap normal. I cracked a rib, then my ankle
Jul 12, 2006
0
59
154
On Wednesday the T5 came out, and the speedo gear was placed back in (Don't ask). It was driven twice that day less than a mile, once to test, once on the way home.

I noticed this morning after about 4 miles, I noticed a whine. I thought it was someone elses car, and when turning onto another street, I continue to hear the noise. It only makes the whine in first if you push it more than normal 5-8mph parking lot speed. Once you get it into 2nd you can hear it. 3rd gear is loudest.

4th & 5th nothing.

I'm figuring one of 3 things.
- The T5 is going bad, low on T5 fluid, or gears?
 
Youl could be low on fluid but its common for T-5's to wine a little bit, mine wines also but it aint to loud. does it vibrate or make the shifter vibrate a little bit?
 
it could be the bearings making noise, also you might want to make sure the tranny bolts to the bell housing are still there. I have seen them missing before and it made the shifter vibrate like crazy.
 
Think about the operation of the trans: 1st-3rd use the countershaft to pass power from the input shaft to the rest of the gears. Fourth gear is direct drive, so it doesn't use the countershaft. Fifth gear reduces the RPM's that the countershaft turns, so you may not be going fast enough in 5th to make it noticeable. Fluid level is important, use Dextron ATF for lubricant.

See http://www.hanlonmotorsports.com/HanlonTIC.html for more help.
 
Think about the operation of the trans: 1st-3rd use the countershaft to pass power from the input shaft to the rest of the gears. Fourth gear is direct drive, so it doesn't use the countershaft. Fifth gear reduces the RPM's that the countershaft turns, so you may not be going fast enough in 5th to make it noticeable. Fluid level is important, use Dextron ATF for lubricant.

See http://www.hanlonmotorsports.com/HanlonTIC.html for more help.

Thanks, thats exactly what I needed. :nice:
 
The shifter itself vibrates and Im convicedit leaks tranny fluid but no one believes me.



That's your problem right there.

T-5's are VERY sensitive when it comes to fluid levels. When the level drops, the bearings start to starve for fluid and they will start to whine. MOST t-5 whining problems are caused by low fluid levels.

Sometimes if you catch it soon enough, a flush and fill will fix the problem ASAP. But if you let it go long enough it will become permanent.

A t-5 should be silent when everything is working well. A shifter sometimes transmits harnonics, but a shifter gasket can cure this problem. Shifter whine usually gets louder in each increasing gear, but not necessarily.
 
Think about the operation of the trans: 1st-3rd use the countershaft to pass power from the input shaft to the rest of the gears. Fourth gear is direct drive, so it doesn't use the countershaft. Fifth gear reduces the RPM's that the countershaft turns, so you may not be going fast enough in 5th to make it noticeable. Fluid level is important, use Dextron ATF for lubricant.

See http://www.hanlonmotorsports.com/HanlonTIC.html for more help.



Your thinking is 100% correct, but i don't think this is the case here. He states his whine gets louder in each sucessive gear.

The whine you are talking about occurs when the mainshaft that the 16 roller bearings between the input shaft and mainshaft begins to score due to heat and lack of fluid.

When this happens, usually it's loudest in 1st gear and reverse because that's where the greatest speed differential exists between the input and main shaft. In 2nd gear it will become quieter and in 3rd gear even quieter. You may even hear it in 5th but it will be just as quiet as 3rd. 4th gear is silent.

Since he said it started in 2nd gear and got louder in 3rd gear, i don't beleive this is his case.

I've disassembled two t-5's where the whine was loudest in 1st and got quieter and found the mainshaft snout completely scored up from lack of fluid....



which leads me back to my original post....check and change your fluid!!
 
If it's whining in those gears most likely it is the fluid level, however if the fluid level is good I would be worried that the front bearing is ready to go...usually a tell tale sign of what is to come.

It is best to pull it out and fix it before it lets loose and takes out a lot more... The first time it happened to me it was $570 worth of parts to make mine right, thank god I build the myself.
 
It was fluid level. It ended up being bone dry. No one believed me that I talked to about the leak, my shop guy that does 80% of time on is mustangs, was saying the seals looked good and didn't believe me, that I was leaking fluid.

The Stang runs fine now. No whine in any gear. :nice: