If it's a 5 spd, daily driver, I still recommend 3.73s. I think the 4.10s in my wife's 01 5spd GT are just a little steep, IMO. 1st gear is more or less useless, and when turning onto a street, 2nd gear is too low and 3rd gear is too high. With my 3.73s, 2nd gear is perfect. Again, just my opinion, my 2 cents.
If you plan to run the quarter often, 4.10s (or maybe more) might be for you. But I am very happy with 3.73s...made a HUGE difference over stock. Gas mileage...who cares?!?! Anyway, depending on how much you like to bury your foot into the firewall will have more impact than what the gears will do.