Little update for everyone. Installed the 190 fuel pump and of course had the same issues (even though the fuel pump was a needed upgrade). Did some more research and decided to try and replace the distributor after we checked and then double checked the timing was set to 10* with no change. Well, the auto parts store distributor got stuck inside the housing, which fortunately didn't do any damage to the cam gear. As an absolute last resort, we said what the hell, and swapped the TFI module from the auto parts store one with the msd one. Lo and behold, that was the ticket. Car runs absolutely amazing now, we just have to get it back to the dyno. It's very frustrating having out of the box parts be bad, especially with a brand like msd, because we were just chasing our tail. I will never buy an msd product again.
Thanks for everyone who responded!