I got mine (the same exact car except for a 5 speed and 2.73s) for 5K, but that was in FL (verts are higher in FL for the obvious reasons). You can look at the blue book, but it will not take into account the anniversary edition since Ford doesn't officially call it that. If all in good working order mechanically and the body isn't too bad off (surface rust versus holes, the top is ok and works good) I would start at $4500. You can always go down. If you are not in a hurry, try the higher and wait. Summer is coming and people will be looking for something like that. If you are in a hurry, I would use the prices 93Fox said. It will probably go somewhere around 3200 (unless you need the $ badly and have to sell now).