Comp Cams - NOT happy

Ozrunner

Member
Nov 4, 2005
44
1
6
I had a few stock Ford roller lifters go bad so I thought I would try something better and searched the net etc.

Most I found seemed basically the same as the Ford roller but after reading Comp Cams site re their High Energy Roller CCA 851-16 which is described as "These High Energy hydraulic roller lifters are for use with the newly designed hydraulic roller cam series from Comp Cams, or as a performance replacement for stock hydraulic roller lifters so I ordered a set.

Being in Oz they arrived today and what did I get in the nice Comp Cams box. but a set of stock standard friggin Ford rollers even with the same markings and they cost me $400. I can get Ford ones for $200 !!!!!

"performance replacement for stock hydraulic roller lifters" my ass. What a friggin lot of BS and I'm far from happy with Comp Cams :mad: .

Has anyone else ordered these and were they different?
 
Send them back.

I beleive they are actually different as far as the insides go....you'll never see the difference. They are actually illegal in some sanctioning bodies

You can buy a FORD stock replacement lifter from Summit for $120, I've use those lifters all the time. We use them in some of our high rpm (8000+) hyd roller set-ups for some class racers.
 
Thanks for the response Rick.

Any idea what maybe different inside ?

I guess from their blurb I was expecting a specific complete roller built by Comp Cams and of a similar CC design as those shown on their page, not the same generic roller as what Ford sells.

Yep the last set I did get from Summit and landed in Oz they cost $200, not a $400 !!!. But only after 1 year on normal use, 3 have gone bad hence I thought I would try something else.

But as Forest said, ***** happens :D
 
Who do you think makes the Ford lifters... ;) It is the way they pump up from what I know...it's all internal.

The first set of Ford lifters I got years ago were in a Crane box..lol There are only a handful of lifter makers, everyone else private labels them.
 
Thanks mate, that info makes me feel a little better as that's the problem I was having with the current ones. 3 would not pump up, consequently my rockers were taking a hammering. so maybe these will be better.

Timing was also crap as I'm making another upper manifold setup using this as the basis, http://members.ozemail.com.au/~jonhel5/graphics/M8.jpg but it will be a few weeks before it's done, so now I have to change the manifold twice :D and that hasn't helped :D

Cheers
JD
 
i bought my comp cams cam kit XE274HR and came with the cam, lifters, springs, retainers, locks, pushrod etc and the lifter are totaly different from stock ones the roller is biguer than the stock one the oil hole is in the side not in fron and they are little lighter and never had no problems with them!
my cousin has some Lunati's lifter and they look ugly on the out side they came like the stock ones used and no problem, dont care how they look outside!
i love comp cams parts....
 
The Ford lifters should be fine. If you had 3 of them go bad I would call something else the culprit causing them to go bad.
As Rick mentioned, there are only a hand full of manufacturers of them.

I know plenty of Class Specific racers shifting 8000 RPM as well and all use the Ford lifters that are mandated.