I didn'y buy the warranty either, especially since Ford upped the standard warranty to 5/50. Transmission choice is purely a personal one, both in preference and in what type of traffic you'll be driving in. I like manual transmissions because I like the way it feels to row the gears and I like the control I get over engine rpm and speed. Any time I bought an automatic I always regretted it and wound up trading the car. But I don't live in a congested area and don't have a lot of traffic to deal with. If I were in a large city I might think differently and chose an automatic. That being said, I test drove both a manual and automatic and I was very impressed with the way the automatic shifted, but not enough to choose it over the manual.