YOU ARE RIGHT!!!
Having a stick (and I've had them) is much more fun than an automatic even though you can still shift and automatic through the gears...
There is nothing like hitting an open road and going through the gears, one by one until you reach max speed... What a great sound and the rumble of those pipes at your back can not be matched...
But in Chicago, there is so much "stop and go" that having a stick is a real pain in the a____...
Not going over 15 or 20 MPH then stopping for several miles with a stick can change a man into a automatic maniac!!!
If I lived where you probably live, I would have gotten a stick...
Mountains and the desert are great experiences with a stick...
Good Luck and "HAPPY HESITATIONS" with your tranny...
Dave