POLL: Collapsed Lifter or not?

Is this a Collapsed Lifter?

  • Yes

    Votes: 2 50.0%
  • No

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • Youve got other problems pal.

    Votes: 1 25.0%

  • Total voters
    4
  • Poll closed .
This is the situation.I had these roller lifters in my Mustang with a B cam. I sold the mustang and kept the motor. Now I didnt want to swap the bottom end to my new mustang so i just put the Heads and Intake on. I left the stock cam in, but used the lifters again they only had like 5k miles on them. Now, when I would start the car there would be this very loud sound, like a thwump thwump, like someone hit the lid of a coffee can. This sound was EXACTLY the same as a time when one of the rockers backed off and came loose. NOW this was only in the first seconds of start up, it made this and wanted to stall. I gave it a touch of gas and then it idled smooth as glass. I could still here an audible click but it wasnt bad lower than a minor exhaust leak, which I definetly didnt have an EX leak. Then as it warmed up and when I got home from going down the street it was much louder. Louder than a lifter "tick" it was still a tick tick but louder than the average lifter that wasnt oiling properly. By the way I dismissed this being a colapsed lifter because when I pulled them out there seemed to be nothing wrong with them. My eye is untrained. So I decided to use them again in my new motor which is on the stand. Based on the info who thinks this a collapsed lifter? Yes or No





 
ever try a stethescope with it running?

now that your in there, you may as well replace them. if that doesnt fix the problem, it sounds like it could be exhaust related, or worse an oiling issue.