If your 351 was bone stock you might be ok with an S-trim. I am no supercharger master, but i have run 3 supercharged cars and this is what i learned along the way. Because you have heads/intake etc. your motor is breathing way more than a stock 351 would. Boost is created by air actually backing up in the intake manifold, so you have positive pressure instead of vacuum. You will see on most supercharger manufacturers websites, the blowers are rated for a motor to a certain HP, because once you near this power level, the blower cant supply enough air (cfm) to the motor to create any decent amount of boost before you overspin the blower, the head unit itself basically has a "redline" just like your motor before it cant handle anymore. That is why you would want to step up to a blower with a higher CFM rating, you will notice that when the CFM rating goes up, so does the HP level the blower can handle. You would have to spin an S-trim (maybe not 8lbs) so hard to create the boost you want, that you may run into problems with the head unit, and also the blower is out of its "efficiency range," that is why i said a YSi may actually make less power than a t-trim at 15psi. Once you hit 20lbs the exact opposite will happen, the t-trim will fall off and the YSi will take off. Hope i helped you understand this a little more.
Anthony