Just an idea, but I've had just as many leaking water pumps as anyone. I've probably changed the gasket 10 times in the past year. Anyway, I bought a new pump and tried it w/ the blue RTV, copper RTV, just gaskets with no RTV, Just RTV and no gaskets, leaked every time one way or another. I finally read on here that someone used some stuff called "The Right Stuff." and it worked.
I went to autozone and a thing of "the right stuff" is around $13, BUT, it did work and I haven't had any more leaks since installing it (knock on wood). I didn't use any gaskets or anything, just "The right stuff."