Weight difference Alum and Copper/Brass

[1Slow90coupe]

Anyone know the weight difference between your average two row aluminum and a three row copper brass radiator.

I am debating between the FMS two row alum, and a three row copper brass from the local parts store. What would you buy?

 

[90lxfoxbody]

i have an all aluminum tig welded rad and it didn't seem much heavier than the stocker i was replacing. i would go with aluminum. in the past when i have used aluminum rads they didn't seem to scale up and get all cruddy as fast as a copper one.

 

[1Slow90coupe]

Which one do you have?

 

[vristang]

I bought a parts store 2 core (it was all they had at the time).

My t-stat has stuck open a few times and the coolant temps hit the low 180s. This tells me that my 197F stat is actually limiting how cool my temps are.

jason

 

[mikemustang289]

I'm willing to bet the weight difference is more a result of the amount coolant it can hold than the actual radiator itself.

How fast are you going where a few pounds is actually going to make a difference? I say forget about weight and go with what will cool better.

 

[Speeds8erM-1]

Aluminum radiators work better when equal sized and will often outcool a larger brass/copper radiator and are lighter soooooo?

 

[90lxfoxbody]

here's the one i bought. they have gone up in price a little since i bought mine, but still a good deal. this will be the last rad you ever buy for your fox unless it gets damaged. these things are very well built. they are a direct fit with stock hoses, too. keep in mind they are for a stick shift, no tranny cooler.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/80-9...ewItemQQcategoryZ33602QQitemZ8049969782QQrdZ1

 

[Daggar]

My t-stat has stuck open a few times and the coolant temps hit the low 180s. This tells me that my 197F stat is actually limiting how cool my temps are.

jason

I sure hope so... that's what they're supposed to do.

 

[ExplodingGopher]

Aluminum radiators work better when equal sized and will often outcool a larger brass/copper radiator and are lighter soooooo?

I dont see how that is true, copper has much better thermal conductivity compared to aluminum, the only realy reason to get an aluminum one is to save weight.

 

[bluevenom867]

I dont see how that is true, copper has much better thermal conductivity compared to aluminum, the only realy reason to get an aluminum one is to save weight.

The aluminum has a higher tensile strength,so the passages can be made larger,witch lets the heat transfer over a greater suface area.Thats why they work better....

 

[ExplodingGopher]

Oh and i have the FMS aluminum 5.0 HD radiator cooling my 460, and it works pretty well, good product, i just wish the tanks were aluminum also.

 

[bluevenom867]

Oh and i have the FMS aluminum 5.0 HD radiator cooling my 460, and it works pretty well, good product, i just wish the tanks were aluminum also.

Do you think the plastic wieghts more?

Or is it cause you cant reapir it as easy if it gets damaged?

 

[ExplodingGopher]

Do you think the plastic wieghts more?

Or is it cause you cant reapir it as easy if it gets damaged?

Easy damage, should have bought the summit one.

 

[bluevenom867]

Easy damage, should have bought the summit one.

Ah,I see what you mean,but I have the same a rad. and that plastic seems pretty sturdy (well,for plastic).

btw,I sent you a PM

 

[vristang]

I sure hope so... that's what they're supposed to do.

I guess I could have made my point a little more clearly.

If my 2-core rad were the limiting factor in my cooling system, then the t-stat sticking open would not cause the coolant temp to drop.


Fords plastic-
I haven't used these before, but I think people tend to over react to the use of plastic on the radiator.
Most likely this is a thermoset, so it will handle VERY hi temps. Even if it is a thermoplastic, it should hold up to cooling system temps very well.

If you get that plastic hot enough to damage or soften it, then you have probably done serious damage to the motor as well. The rad. should be the least of your concerns for hi temp damage.

 

[1Slow90coupe]

Oh and i have the FMS aluminum 5.0 HD radiator cooling my 460, and it works pretty well, good product, i just wish the tanks were aluminum also.

So if you had it to do over, Would you still buy the same one? I like items that are well built and fit right. I don't mind to pay $200-$260 I just want to only buy one. I have made bad parts choices in the past, and I hate to waste $$$$.

 

[blackstangt]

that radiator looks like a great deal... aluminum radiators, at least aftermarket ones like this are better at cooling, the weight diff will be minimal if at all. I had cooling probs in the summer with my stock one, so i upgraded to an afco aluminum one, with 160 thermostat, it runs at 160 except in traffic, but has never gone past 190.

 

[ExplodingGopher]

So if you had it to do over, Would you still buy the same one? I like items that are well built and fit right. I don't mind to pay $200-$260 I just want to only buy one. I have made bad parts choices in the past, and I hate to waste $$$$.

get the all aluminum one from summit then, looks great too.