The car just lacks style, looks like a kit car. $35k for a car that is one year old that cost $55k new should tell you enough. $20,000 loss in one year?
My buddy's stock z06 ran a 12.2 without touching it, not even tires.
I'd look to other used cars.
Such as:
CTS-V
04 cobra vert
I'll agree with you on one thing, the nissans, g35's and m3 i wouldn't even consider. Although a g35 coupe looks good, it totally lacks power and potential.
It's not only about the numbers, having a balance of power and style is important. I bet when you get out of your mustang and you look back at it, you say to yourself "yup, that's mine",
think you'll do the same after you get out of that go cart?
Not trying to give you a hard time, i just don't picture a man getting out of that car, i picture his wife getting out of it. And if you bagged her with a fancy car, you've got much more to worry about for the rest of your life.
BTW, i don't drive a mustang to pick up chicks, i drive it because it's loud obnoxious, and suits my personality.