Check to make sure the same color gear on the output shaft of the tranny is the same. I believe they came in 6 tooth (black), 7 tooth (yellow), and 8 tooth (green). I have had this problem before and it turned out I had the 8 tooth and I needed the yellow. Different years had different colors on otherwise same transmission. I had a link to a chart that showed the different combos, but it is dead now.