A question for you 2nd Amendment folks...

BlownFiveLiter

have car, will race....wait, it doesn't run
15 Year Member
Nov 29, 1999
3,133
18
108
Chicagoland
I'm not sure if this made national news (probably not), but last night here in my quiet little town of around 20k people, there was a police involved shooting which killed a man who fired on officers after they stopped him in the local high school parking lot. Story

This, combined with a separate incident which I believe may have easily just been kids, but may also have been someone scouting homes to burglarize (someone knocked on one of the windows on the side of my house at around 6AM on a Friday and again on Monday, shortly after my dad left for work) has gotten me thinking about buying a gun. My mom already has one that was my grandfather's, but it hasn't been fired in many years, and I doubt the ammo she has for it would even fire it's so old. I went out looking earlier today and happened across a steal of a deal on this Smith & Wesson Sigma .40 cal for $289. It's used, but at a reputable gun shop in this area, so I know they would have inspected it and determined that it was in saleable condition. The thing looks brand new as a matter of fact. I've done considerable reading on guns over the years and have wanted one for some time, so this is making my decision a little easier, but I'm looking for the opinion of: "is this too much gun for home defense?" I like the idea of having a gun equipped with ammo that according to different sources has a "one shot stoppping power" with an effectiveness of anywhere from 71-96% without penetration exceeding I believe around 12 inches, so I'm not shooting through someone and into my neighbor's house if they're dumb enough to try to break in with my 180 and 100lb dogs (English Mastiff and German Shepard). Opinions?
 
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,234781,00.html

Check out this story about a local town near me.

I grew up out in the middle of nowhere and we always had a shot gun and a semi auto 22 in the house ready to fire "just in case." I live in a nice area now, but I still keep my 30-06 rifle next to my bed. the only problem with it is that if I ever needed to use it, I'd probably end up shooting into my neighbors house too.
 
ask guero and the green gt they gots some guns for protection or fun.

for me i am afraid i might snap and cause an acident, if you dont like the aspect of a gun get a TASER. and get your dogs to sit on the intruder.
 
For home defense a shotgun is the best bet. It has an intimidating sound, and if the guy doesn't run when you pump it, you probably won't miss with some buckshot loaded. You can pick up a Mossberg 500 for like $250-$300.

Personally, I have a Glock 17 I got brand new for $433 after tax(Deputy friend got me a discount). But I don't keep ammo in the house and the gun is usually locked anyways. It's strictly for practice.
 
I did think about a shotgun actually. Racking a shotgun while pointing it at someone just means business, and it'd honestly be a lot easier to mop up their p*ss when they froze from having a 12 gauge pointing at them, than their blood when I hit them with 5 or 6 rounds from a .40 cal. The only reason I ruled a shotgun out is the fact that it's useless if I'm struggling with someone. If I had a pistol, I have a fighting chance in close quarters, and if I'm going to lose the gun, the last thing I can do as it's being taken from me is drop the magazine out. Most newer guns, that .40 S&W included, disable the firing pin if the magazine is ejected, so I wouldn't be shot by my own gun.
 
The .40 caliber is a very nice round because it gives you more power than a 9mm but less recoil than a .45ACP. For home defense I would recommend hollow points. Experiment with different ammo though, because .40 cal's are somewhat finicky with the type of ammo they use. Just depending on the tolerances of the gun, one type of bullet will work better then the other.

If you wanted to spend the extra money, you could buy a laser sight to mount on your gun. If you are inexperienced in will greatly increase your chances of hitting them, plus it provides the "intimidation" factor.
 
The dogs are your best "first defense". Most burglars are going to skip a house with dogs, looking for an easier target. If someone gets through them, a taser or 9mm is prolly not going to be enough. A shotgun will stop even meth heads.(Mossburg 500=awesome gun. And cheap. You can interchange barrels for home defense, small game and even deer hunting. Very versatile. You can even have an "illegal" barrel for the close quarters issue that you mentioned.)
On the other hand, a .40 cal is very popular with law enforcement for the reasons you mentioned. Stopping power and little "overpenetration". My next handgun will prolly be a 40 cal Beretta or Glock.
I currently have a Ruger P89 (9mm-17 rounds, hard to beat) and a .410 Mossberg 500 (I squirrel hunt.)

I would also recommend that you pick up that Smith for under $300. It's a good deal.
 
When I travel for work I'm packing two pistols.. A 40 cal Glock and a 41 Mag taurus. The 41 Mag is my Bear gun but I still take it. The 40 cal. is an excellent self defense weapon. If it ever comes down to it, shoot to kill..In our ridiculous society you could get sued by a burglar that you shot for breaking into "YOUR" home.
 
Most newer guns, that .40 S&W included, disable the firing pin if the magazine is ejected, so I wouldn't be shot by my own gun.

Is it the Sigma? Im gussing yes cuz of the price. If so, it will fire with the magazine out. And so does Glock. Any how a .40 is perfect i think for self defense at home. The shot gun is to, but i think it would be more graffic and will tear his ass up. .40 round i think is like a 85 percent chance youll take him down in the chest i think. Depending on the gun it may have less recoil than a 40. I know my 40 has some recoil, but my friend has a 45 Glock and has alot less recoil than me. I personally like the 40. Any how shoot to kill lol!!!!
 
just an observation...

it's interesting how different American and Canadian societies view the social acceptability of owning a handgun

again, just an observation

Not just Canadian. North and South here in the states. I shot my first handgun when I was 9. But I know people from the north that are in their mid-20's and have never shot a gun.
IMO, it's actually kinda sad if owning a gun is viewed as a negative. I grew up shooting guns, and I got my Glock for my 21st B-day; but it's always been for strictly recreational purposes(self defense or killing was never what I was learning).
If your society sees guns as only a bad thing then that just means you have a more violent society. Let's take NYC or Chicago: the only people that can legally have guns are police, so everyone else that has one just has it illegally so they can kill people.
How would you view a society that thinks that the only people that own....let's say matches, use them for burning down houses with people in them?
 
Not just Canadian. North and South here in the states. I shot my first handgun when I was 9. But I know people from the north that are in their mid-20's and have never shot a gun.
IMO, it's actually kinda sad if owning a gun is viewed as a negative. I grew up shooting guns, and I got my Glock for my 21st B-day; but it's always been for strictly recreational purposes(self defense or killing was never what I was learning).
If your society sees guns as only a bad thing then that just means you have a more violent society. Let's take NYC or Chicago: the only people that can legally have guns are police, so everyone else that has one just has it illegally so they can kill people.
How would you view a society that thinks that the only people that own....let's say matches, use them for burning down houses with people in them?

It's illegal to have guns in NYC and Chicago?? Our country needs to wake the fu*k up.. Does anyone know what happened in Australia when they made guns illegal.. All the criminals still kept them and the law abiding citizens were defenseless. I will always carry one be legal or not.