rpburnette
Member
Gearbanger 101 said:Really.......I disagree. Go take a car with an aluminum manifold around the block a few times or through stop and go traffic in summer weather (which oddly enough is very similar to the line ups you face on a busy weekend at the track) and see how it feels to put your hand on it.Now, go do the same with your Mustang running it’s stock PI manifold and place your hand on one of the intake runners. The fact that it's not searing off your fingerprints should tell you that there's a huge temperature between the two. I’d bet a couple of hundred degree difference at minimum. This is going to make a difference, however small to the temperature of the incoming air charge. And by your admission for the need for one to place bags of ice on the aluminum manifold to keep intake temperatures at bay also confirms this. Doing this same trick to a plastic manifold will net better results still.
![]()
I have a better test for you. Take some plastic and Al and and subject it to say 200F temperature for 20 minutes, which is hotter? Answer, they are both at 200 degrees. No matter what material you use, in less it is a highly insulating material, heat transfer will occur it just occurs at different rates. This being said, using ice on either plastic or an Al intake at the track will work the same, but the Al. will loose its heat faster. The reason companies use plastic is b/c of cost. They can get a smooth finish and the same performance at a cheaper price than using metal, especially considering the rising price of metal in the past 10 or so years. Since Al has a higher heat transfer rate compared to plastic than the Al intake will allow more heat to be transfered to the air inside of the intake resulting in slightly higher intake temps, but considering the slight temp difference(a 100 degree differnence is slight when talking heat transfer) of inside the intake and outside the intake and the volume of air flowing inside the intake, it won't make that much of a difference, like I said before maybe a couple HP difference if everything is equal. If you are not convinced than leave your hand on the plastic intake a little longer and see if it doesn't start hurting.
One last comment. Of course plastic is better than Al for heat transfer reasons, but it will not cost you that much in power. The reason aftermarket companies make them out of metal is b/c they usually don't have the resources to make them out of plastic, therefore metal is there only choice. Plastic has to be done in volume to decrease the cost of production
Now, go do the same with your Mustang running it’s stock PI manifold and place your hand on one of the intake runners. The fact that it's not searing off your fingerprints should tell you that there's a huge temperature between the two. I’d bet a couple of hundred degree difference at minimum. This is going to make a difference, however small to the temperature of the incoming air charge. And by your admission for the need for one to place bags of ice on the aluminum manifold to keep intake temperatures at bay also confirms this. Doing this same trick to a plastic manifold will net better results still.
. But maybe aI will Email them and explain my position, that I will buy it solely on price.
Maybe the group buy thing will net a REALLY good discount