xc_myers_06 said:
yea you could just look at affirmative action and then the whites would benefit from it by being a minority i can't believe that crap is actually valid. That is B/S! its not my prob. that the average scores for minorities is lower then whites for instance. I don't know i mean you should look at ppl the same but diff races come from diff. cultures and are just diff. Such as physically we are exactly the same in about every way except pigment color. But mentally the beliefs are quite a bit diff. I still disagree with whites becoming the minority in america but that is my thought. Maybe all of them will come to America and i can move to Cancun. That works for me!
Well the whole reason i think the "aide" is given to minorities is because of the past and how whites held minorities back. So who is to say when that it is even again? Will it ever be? I wonder how things would be if whites didnt do what they did in the past. I wonder how it would be if everyone was treated fairly with the same opportunities. That would be interesting. And yes, minorities can succeed. They do succeed. But for the average minority coming from a poor neighborhood, it is harder. Just like its harder for a white coming from the same neighborhood. But sometimes, not as hard.
But thats why i say look at the class...not the color of the person. To me it should be based off where u grow up at. U of M has a lot of arguing going on with the topic. Blacks do get "points" for their application. But so do people who are from the upper peninsula. And i wonder what the percentages are of whites/minorities of those students. All the ones i have met are white.
Black95GTS said:
No its not. As a middle class white guy, with 55K in college loans to pay back, its not ignorant at all.
Tell that to my Fraternity brother who is black and GOT PAID 6000 dollars a year to go to engineering college. He bought a brand new 2004 Harley Davidson F150 his Junior year. By the way, his dad has 6 classic muscle cars in a heated garage independent from his house, which is about 3 times the size of mine. Hey, if I was in his shoes though, I'd do the same thing!
Financial aid should be based on merit. You want it, you work for it, you earn it. Bring your grades, bring your SATs, bring your ACTs, bring your AP scores. Being a minority or poor does not make you more deserving then the rich or the majority.
Adam
It IS ignorant to say that just because you are "white". And IMO its ignorant to say "HEY IM BLACK, GIVE ME HELP!" also. It goes both ways. Yea, some may not like how the system works right now, but guess what, the system has been screwed up for a longgggg time. It goes both ways. Both sides of the fence can complain about just as many things.
Thats why i went on to say its classes that matter. Forget your skin, where did u go to school? 1 parent home? Income? etc etc etc. These are the kind of things that i believe make the difference between students. Obviously your black friend didnt come from a under priveledged(sp) home. Therefore, he shouldnt be getting all that aide.
And im sorry, we'll agree to disagree, but being a minority(and guess whos in most poor areas) DOES make u more deserving. Why? Cause the rich white,black, asian whatever kids have more resources then you. They have better schools. Better "homes" to go home to. Better teachers. MORE chances to succeed. Where as in poor neighborhoods, there is non of that. A student coming from a poor neighborhood has the odds stacked against him. The playing field isnt level to being with. Just my opinion.
EDIT: when i say whites, i mean in general and mainly historically just so no one takes offense. Im mixed, half white/half black so i can see on both sides of the fence.