Caldwell, this past summer I looked at cars for my wife. I looked at the 350Z convertible, S2000, Z3's, Audi TT and A4 cabrio, miata, Mr2 spyder, etc. Of them all I liked the S2000, MR2 SPyder, and 350Z the best. I ended up getting her a '00 MR2 Spyder because:
1. It was the cheapest
2. It was the rarest of all the cars I looked at (they only made 5000/yr from 2000-2005 and I NEVER see them around here)
3. It gets over 30mpg which was HUGE for us this summer
4. Its the one my wife liked the most.
As you know I was without my car all summer, so this little MR2 was my "fun" car this summer, and honestly its a blast to drive. I got more compliments when I drove this car than I ever did in the mustang. Having said that though I'd NEVER choose it over my car, but its nice to have as a secondary "fun" car. The S2000 and 350Z were WAY too much money IMO for the car you get, but the same holds true for nearly all the cars I listed. I LOVE the new saturn sky, but if it follows the solstice's track record for delivery to dealer showrooms it won't be out for a few years.