What do you guys think ?

TheDamned

"I am Canadian and Damned for it!"
Jul 22, 2003
457
0
48
Montréal, Québec, Canada
Hey,

Not really my kind of post on SN but what the heck.
Since 2 weeks i'm dating a 17 yo girl (I'm 21)
She's super sweet, VERY hot and is not attached to superficial things like most teens aged around that age. She's a virgin in all aspects and that's what I like of her. I think i'm her first real boyfriend... I've seen other girls before and stuff but that girl is so sweet and innoncent, i like her alot...

What do you guys\girls think about a 21 dating a 17 yo ? Is it bad\stupid at your eyes or it's kinda normal ?

Thanks for your inputs.
 
TheDamned said:
Hey,

Not really my kind of post on SN but what the heck.
Since 2 weeks i'm dating a 17 yo girl (I'm 21)
She's super sweet, VERY hot and is not attached to superficial things like most teens aged around that age. She's a virgin in all aspects and that's what I like of her. I think i'm his first real boyfriend... I've seen other girls before and stuff but that girl is so sweet and innoncent, i like her alot...

What do you guys\girls think about a 21 dating a 17 yo ? Is it bad\stupid at your eyes or it's kinda normal ?

Thanks for your inputs.
BUSTED
View attachment 476157 View attachment 476159
 
Ouch....you just got owned...

I see no problems with it man....if she's (he's) hot and old enough to make her (his) own decisions, then park your beef bus in tuna town, if you know what i mean
 
Personally, I don't think its a good idea. A lot of people use the "she's mature for her age" as a way to justify the age difference, but it usually doesn't hold true unless she has been living on her own and supporting herself (living as an adult), but then again her "peers" typically would still be a maturity level far below that and more on the level of a tyical high school kid which would tend to bring her's down I'd think.

Age generally doesn't matter once you are out of highschool and living on your own, but the difference is profound when dealing with people that are still in highschool IMO.

You two are 5yrs apart in age, do you think her maturing level is a lot different than a 12yr olds? That's only 5 years. I know I was a hell of a lot more mature at 21 than I was at 17. Its an extreme example but one that illustrates how much changes in 5yrs.

I just see more harm than good coming from such a situation. I've seen it happen a few times to friends and such and it have never had a good outcome. JMO I wish the best for you, but I'd be VERY cautious if I were you.
 
Killercanary said:
Age generally doesn't matter once you are out of highschool and living on your own, but the difference is profound when dealing with people that are still in highschool IMO.

i totally agree! until you're hit w/ the realization, it's very hard to see the difference.

if you're happy w/ her and you don't have to deal w/ ridiculous things that a high school girl can throw at you, i say it's cool.

i dated a girl a couple summers ago that was just out of high school--after a couple weeks, i couldn't stand her and called it off. she was pretty mature, but she still had the h.s. mind-set.
 
Im with Paul...could work out and it couldnt. But i definately think the odds are against u. Sure people say girls mature faster than guys....even if she "seems" mature....shes not. You said it enough when u said that u were her first "real" boyfriend. So that would tell me that there is a TON of crap she has not learned about relationships...and serious ones at that. You're gonna be the test rabbit so get ready for that stress.

Also, a lot of young people, even 21 year olds, havent grown up and realized what life is really about. And like killer said, being 17 makes that even worse.

Not trying to scare u off but its just been my experience. My girl is a year younger than me....kinda funny as the same dumb crap i did comes about a year later from her end. There are exceptions but i wouldnt take dating a 17year old while im 21 now seriously...it would have to be proven to me. Otherwise in 6 months u'll be back asking for help on how to handle a specific situation.


Edit: The other paul got in before i finished. To add to that, even just after highschool, depending on the person, the same BS goes WELL into college. One thing i will say....if u're trying to make it serious, i'd bet my money that u'll have plenty of stress and a lot of stupid fights about BS. Not trying to shoot down your hopes and dreams, cause i hope the best for u, but thats just been my experience.
 
Finally some nice inputs.

Yeah I took all this in consideration, like I said, the girl isn't in the usual 17-18yo superficial mindset. You know the one dreaming about going to shop in New-York, or meeting Tupac, or having bling bling chromed wheels on her pink civic. She's out of HS in 2 months and heading to college to be a lawyer. She's VERY smart... I'll continue with the relationship and see how it turns out... Thanks for the advices, keep 'em coming.

edit: Paul, we have 4 yrs age diff.. I just turned 21 and she turned 17.