Ive had bbk shorties and Mac shorties, I cant tell the differences between either, both had similar power gains and sound the same, they both fit just the same and both dont leak...the only thing I remember is bbk seem to not rust/ loose their color as fast, possibly because bbk are higher quality...
It's not so much a matter of quality as a matter of coatings.
The two most popular options on Mac Headers are the standard HTS silicon based coating (which you find on their basic $170-$200 shorty headers) and the much better ceramic coating. Almost everyone who buys Mac headers just buys the standard stuff, a lot of people aren't very aware that Mac even offers an actual ceramic coating. This situation is made worse because so many people mistake the "silver paint color" of Mac's HTS coating for a ceramic coating, which it certainly is not. This coating is similar, though slightly longer lasting, to the generic black paint you find on inexpensive headers. It's purpose is to keep the steel from corroding in the box before it reaches the customer, not to keep the headers from rusting on the car. Heat from the exhaust eventually burns off the Mac HTS coating just like header paint, and for people who don't expect this it can be a surprise.
BBK, just like Mac, has two main options. The difference is BBK's budget option is a Chrome coating instead of a silicon based coating. BBK also offers a ceramic coating. While the chrome won't burn off like header paint or Mac's grey-silver high-temp silicone, it will blue very quickly and will not retain its shine. Surface rust also develops fairly quickly if driven often.
The moral of the story: Whether you buy budget headers with black paint, Mac HTS, or BBK chrome, the finish will also corrode, peel, or generally deteriorate. A ceramic inside & out thermal coating, either from the factory or done by Jet-Hot or HPC, is the best way to prolong a header's finish and the best way to protect it from corrosion.