Drivetrain 89....going to 2nd

justin82

Active Member
Sep 14, 2017
334
17
48
ok, so I'm no stranger to manual transmissions...when I go from 1st to 2nd it grinds, then everytime after that I have to consciencely think when I'm shifting to 2nd everytime after that....seems to happen after the car sits over night and on first start up....any ideas?

thanks guys
 
  • Sponsors (?)


Without being there couldn't tell ya, cept check the clutch adjustment, I like it about mid peddle, cable should have no slack in it but not pulling on the fork but slightly. Now if ya gots a ton of miles on it I would go new clutch assembly, open up the trans and rebuild/repair worn parts and get an aftermarket shifter. I'd also go through the driveshaft (new u joints and a balance) now you got no worries for ever. JMO
On a side note, the rubber bushing that the cable uses through the firewall gets wonky, I'd get a aftermarket adjuster to replace that bushing and a quadrant to replace the factory adjuster under the dash.
 
If you don't have any problems shifting into first when the car isn't moving, clutch adjustment isn't your problem; it's in the transmission.



Clutch Adjustment for stock and aftermarket setups
Revised 28-Apr-2016 to include need for longer cable with single hook quadrant

Clutch adjustment with stock cable and quadrant
There is a self-adjusting mechanism for the clutch cable. As the clutch wears the cable tension changes, that is why there is a self-adjusting mechanism built into the clutch pedal. There is a toothed plastic quadrant with a ratchet pawl that engages the quadrant. As you pull up on the clutch pedal, it ratchets and takes any slack out of the clutch cable. Mess around with the pedal or even bump it while the end that fits in the clutch fork is loose, and it tries to take up the slack in the cable. That has the effect of shortening the cable.

Do the clutch adjustment first before considering any other problems. With the stock plastic quadrant and cable, pull up on the clutch pedal until it comes upward toward you. It will make a ratcheting sound as the self-adjuster works. To release to tension of the stock quadrant, use a screwdriver to lift the ratchet paw up and out of engagement with the quadrant teeth.

You can use a screwdriver to lift the ratchet pawl off the quadrant teeth. That will allow you to move the quadrant to allow more slack in the cable. If the cable is too loose, pull up on the pedal. The ratchet pawl will allow the quadrant to take up the slack in the cable and lock the adjustment.

Adjustable cables are used when the plastic quadrant is replaced with an aftermarket metal quadrant. The downside to this setup is that you have to get under the car to adjust the clutch. Add a firewall adjuster to an adjustable cable setup and you can spare yourself from getting back under the car to make any fine adjustment that you desire.

The fancy 2 and 3 hook quadrants are for use with stock length cable and a firewall adjuster. Use the firewall adjuster and screw in and out to take the slack out of the cable and get the clutch engagement point just where you want it.

Binding clutch cable
A binding clutch cable will make the clutch very stiff. If the cable is misrouted or has gotten too close to the exhaust, it will definitely bind. The binding common to adjustable cables is often due to misplacement of the adjusting nuts on the fork end of the cable. This will also cause the cable to wear and fray. Both nuts should be on the back side of the fork so that the domed nut faces the fork and the other nut serves as jam or locknut to the domed nut.

Clutch pedal adjustment
Clutch pedal adjustment with aftermarket quadrant and cable: I like to have the clutch completely disengaged and still have about 1.5” travel left before the pedal hits the floor. This means that I have only about 1” of free play at the top before the pedal starts to disengage the clutch. Keep in mind that these figures are all approximate. When properly adjusted, there will not be any slack in the clutch cable. You will have 4-15 lbs. preload on the clutch cable. With a non-adjustable cable and a firewall adjuster, the cable needs to go in the second hook of the quadrant. Single hook quadrants used with a firewall adjuster may make the clutch too tight, causing it to slip. The possible exception to this is the Maximum Motorsports cable which is a bit longer to make it work with a single hook quadrant.

Adjustable clutch cable tips:
Loosening the cable adjustment nut (throwout bearing arm moves to the rear of the car) moves the disengagement point towards the floor.

Tightening the cable adjustment nut (throwout bearing arm moves to the front of the car) moves the disengagement point towards the top of the pedal.

Firewall adjuster tips
Turning the firewall adjuster IN makes the engagement point closer to the floor since it loosens the cable. You have to push the pedal to the floor to disengage the clutch. Too loose a cable and the clutch won't completely disengage and shifting will be difficult. Gears will grind and you may have difficulty getting the transmission in first gear when stopped.

Turning the firewall adjuster OUT makes the engagement point farther from the floor since it tightens the cable. You push a short distance to disengage the clutch. Too tight a cable will cause clutch slippage.

Aftermarket solutions to the problem:
The quadrant needs to be replaced if you use any type of aftermarket cable or adjuster. My preference is a Ford Racing quadrant, adjustable cable and Steeda firewall adjuster. The adjustable Ford Racing cable is just as good as the stock OEM cable. It allows a greater range of adjustment than a stock cable with a aftermarket quadrant and firewall adjuster. Combined with the Steeda adjuster, it lets you set the initial cable preload and then fine tune the clutch engagement point to your liking without getting under the car.

Using a stock OEM cable, firewall adjuster and a single hook quadrant may result in not having any free pedal travel before the clutch starts to disengage. I found this out the hard way.

See Summit Racing - High Performance Car and Truck Parts l 800-230-3030 for the following parts.

Ford Racing M-7553-B302 - Ford Racing V-8 Mustang Adjustable Clutch Linkage Kits - Overview - SummitRacing.com Cable and quadrant assembly $90

The Ford Racing Adjustable cable is available as a separate part:
Clutch Cable, Adjustable, Ford, Mercury, 5.0L, Kit FMS-M-7553-C302_HE_xl.jpg

[url=http://www.summitracing.com/parts/SDA-555-7021/]Steeda Autosports 555-7021 - Steeda Autosports Firewall Cable Adjusters - Overview - SummitRacing.com
Steeda firewall adjuster. $40

575166.jpg


Fix for the quadrant end of the cable popping out of the quadrant when installing a replacement cable courtesy of Grabbin' Asphalt
attachments\575167
[/url]
 

Attachments

  • ?temp_hash=3b781a008f68f70d0bde9d6310e08fdb.gif
    ?temp_hash=3b781a008f68f70d0bde9d6310e08fdb.gif
    25 KB · Views: 112
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I'd find it unlikely it's anything to do with the clutch.
If I remember correctly the blocking rings are the issue (I could be wrong, it's been a while).
Regardless, if you pull the trans, rebuild or have it rebuilt with a small parts rebuild kit.
Don't let the issue drag on, over the years I've found that transmission problems only get worse and could possibly land up costing you more money.
 
oh man....u really think?!!...ughhh
Unfortunately I really do think so.
The reality is that a clutch problem would most likely affect something other than just shifting into 2nd.

I've ruined a few t5s and my first one started with grinding going into 2nd...
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 1 user
If it's not grinding going into 1st, then it's nothing with the clutch.

Likely, synchronizer (or some part of it) failing. 1-2 synchronizer. That said, you don't just want to order and 1-2 synchro and replace it alone. You will want to remove the trans, pull it apart and inspect it carefully. Usually if it's grinding into any gear, that gear's teeth are damaged/rounded. Depending on "how badly" they're damaged, they may need to be replaced-and it doesn't take much to cause issues. That said, if you have to replace any gears, they can get expensive quick. at that point it would wise to weigh the options of rebuilding with the parts needed vs replacing it with a new one. I have seen way too many times-and even in my own stuff-that repairing it is more expensive and MUCH more time consuming than just replacing it. At that point, it's still possible to sell your broken T5 for parts, which would help you recover some of what you had to spend on the new one. It used to be that a T5 rebuild was fairly inexpensive. Those days have passed unfortunately.
 
hey guys, need a little more advice
i called the tranny shop my guy refers people to....I'm looking at a couple hundred just to pull it and look at it...would I be better served to just find a good used tranny and have them put it in?

thanks
 
Here in NJ, you would likely be looking at about $250 to pull it and reinstall it. So a couple hundred sounds about right.

I doubt it's your shifting, it's real simple, you push the clutch in and it should go into gear whatever gear you shift into.

I'm not so sure i'd take the risk on some random transmission that you most likely will get little to no warranty with and almost certainly won't be able to try out first. My guess is if there are not hard parts (gears, shafts) that need to be replaced, a competent place could pull and rebuild your trans for $1000 or less without a new clutch.
Remember, t5's are now 25 years old and they come from cars that were typically beat on. While i'm all for used parts, it's still a gamble.

Honestly, someone that knows their way around a t5 should be able to estimate the job based on your description.
 
If it's not grinding going into 1st, then it's nothing with the clutch.

Likely, synchronizer (or some part of it) failing. 1-2 synchronizer. That said, you don't just want to order and 1-2 synchro and replace it alone. You will want to remove the trans, pull it apart and inspect it carefully. Usually if it's grinding into any gear, that gear's teeth are damaged/rounded. Depending on "how badly" they're damaged, they may need to be replaced-and it doesn't take much to cause issues. That said, if you have to replace any gears, they can get expensive quick. at that point it would wise to weigh the options of rebuilding with the parts needed vs replacing it with a new one. I have seen way too many times-and even in my own stuff-that repairing it is more expensive and MUCH more time consuming than just replacing it. At that point, it's still possible to sell your broken T5 for parts, which would help you recover some of what you had to spend on the new one. It used to be that a T5 rebuild was fairly inexpensive. Those days have passed unfortunately.

well, went to drive it around the block the other day,...had to forcefully shift into each gear, felt like I was gonna break the shifter just to get it into gear....drove ot to work the next day to see of I could work the problem , which I have before....didn't work....so now I have possibly 2 problems?....ideas, again?...lol....thanks guys