Need some help fellas....whine noise after gear install

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#1

• Jan 12, 2004

• #1

Need some help fellas....whine noise after gear install...Deceleration Only

ok i got my FMS 3.73's installed last thurs with a custom diablo chip. i'm an automatic so i needed the chip. Anyways, he told me before i even got in the car that there is some whining ONLY WHEN DECELERATING from 50mph to 30mph and not to worry it is normal and that it wasn't coming from the gears it was coming from the tranny. Now he did do some tranny stuff with the chip , line pressure shift points whatever....my question is WHAT is really causing the whine?? is he correct or what? am i ok? sorry for the long post

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#2

• Jan 12, 2004

• #2

anyone?

 

T

TARZAN

New Member

Apr 25, 2003

446

0

0

Philly MS

Jan 12, 2004

#3

• Jan 12, 2004

• #3

Tranny shouldn't be whining, and 3.73's shouldn't whine either....

I'd be headed back manl.

-Will

 

T

TARZAN

New Member

Apr 25, 2003

446

0

0

Philly MS

Jan 12, 2004

#4

• Jan 12, 2004

• #4

Who did the install for you? A friend, shop, or local mechanic?

-Will

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#5

• Jan 12, 2004

• #5

i JUST got off the phone with him...he said it is normal with AOD trannys and that every car is diffrent some make noise some don't. If i put the car in neutral the noise goes away so he said that it isn't the gears. so now what?

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#6

• Jan 12, 2004

• #6

TARZAN said:

Who did the install for you? A friend, shop, or local mechanic?

-Will

Click to expand...

a local mustang speed shop. he's been around for years and has done hundreds of gear installs...for whatever it's worth

 

'01 Steed

Founding Member

Aug 2, 2002

482

0

16

Michigan

Jan 12, 2004

#7

• Jan 12, 2004

• #7

00VERT GT said:

...If i put the car in neutral the noise goes away so he said that it isn't the gears. so now what?

Click to expand...

That's not necessarily true. In neutral, there is no load on the rearend. Can he give the readings he took for backlash and runout? Also pinion bearing preload (new or used?). See if you can get those numbers from him, and post them.
It may very well be the tranny, but putting it in neutral doesn't isolate one from the other.
He's right about it being fairly normal. Some have little or no whine, some have more. I guess it's what you're willing to live with. Mine has a very small amount of whine at highway speeds...barely audible, and I know mine was installed correctly.

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#8

• Jan 12, 2004

• #8

[QUOTE='01 Steed]He's right about it being fairly normal. Some have little or no whine, some have more. I guess it's what you're willing to live with. Mine has a very small amount of whine at highway speeds...barely audible, and I know mine was installed correctly.[/QUOTE]

So it won't hurt my car in any way then? assuming that the install was done correctly?

 

'01 Steed

Founding Member

Aug 2, 2002

482

0

16

Michigan

Jan 12, 2004

#9

• Jan 12, 2004

• #9

If it was done correctly, you should have no rear end related problems. Just keep an ear on it, see if it changes -- louder, quieter, broader rpm range, anything. Keep him informed it gets worse. But my guess is, you'll be fine.

How do like it otherwise? I think this mod is the best mod for the money, hands down!

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#10

• Jan 12, 2004

• #10

[QUOTE='01 Steed]If it was done correctly, you should have no rear end related problems. Just keep an ear on it, see if it changes -- louder, quieter, broader rpm range, anything. Keep him informed it gets worse. But my guess is, you'll be fine.

How do like it otherwise? I think this mod is the best mod for the money, hands down![/QUOTE]

i LOVE THEM man.....lol can't believe i waited so long before getting them. Nice to be able to squawk 2nd now for the first time. I'm just real protective of my stang and hate it when i hear anything out of the ordinary...just do'nt want anything to happen to her.

 

D

DerekStangGT

My package is in the mail!

Feb 18, 2003

1,068

0

36

Jan 12, 2004

#11

• Jan 12, 2004

• #11

i had the gear whine. my mecjanic who did the install said it was normal for the first few miles to whine. if after ~100-200 miles it still whines, then i would think somthing is wrong. and the whine you hear IS from the gears, not the tranny

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#12

• Jan 12, 2004

• #12

what does it mean when the whine only happens when i decelerate?

 

D

DerekStangGT

My package is in the mail!

Feb 18, 2003

1,068

0

36

Jan 12, 2004

#13

• Jan 12, 2004

• #13

00VERT GT said:

what does it mean when the whine only happens when i decelerate?

Click to expand...

im no expert, but i think its from the gears winding down w/o the accel. pressure, or somthin like that. once again, im no expert

 

'01 Steed

Founding Member

Aug 2, 2002

482

0

16

Michigan

Jan 12, 2004

#14

• Jan 12, 2004

• #14

It's all related to the contact pattern on the front and back side of the ring gear. Your tech may have set it up so that the pinion gear rides closer the toe or the heel of the ring gear. Do a search on ring gear setups on the net. There's alot out there that explains this stuff.

 

00VERT GT

New Member

Jun 30, 2003

376

0

0

SW Florida

Jan 12, 2004

#15

• Jan 12, 2004

• #15

[QUOTE='01 Steed] Your tech may have set it up so that the pinion gear rides closer the toe or the heel of the ring gear. [/QUOTE]

would this in any way hurt my car?
sorry for such noob questions

 

'01 Steed

Founding Member

Aug 2, 2002

482

0

16

Michigan

Jan 12, 2004

#16

• Jan 12, 2004

• #16

Nah. Some setups favor street applications, others favor auto-x. Shouldn't affect you one way or the other.

 

budguy1967

New Member

Sep 18, 2002

43

0

0

Wichita, Kansas

Jan 12, 2004

#17

• Jan 12, 2004

• #17

Just had 4.30 gears installed in my 97 with no gear whine. I was told by the installer that the contact pattern has everything to do with gear whine. The installer on mine had a colored lube that he put on the gear to test the contact. The contact should be in the middle of the tooth depthwise, and centered from the top to bottom of the tooth.

Problems from misaligned gears are excessive noise and a shorter gear life. Better to get them done right the first time.

 

cap42

New Member

Jul 23, 2003

398

0

0

Bolingbrook IL

Jan 12, 2004

#18

• Jan 12, 2004

• #18

My tranny whines when I decelerate at any point as well as my rear end, if I engine break and get up to 4k rpm's my g/f makes fun of my car saying it sounds like a jet airplane landing the tranny howls as well when I accelerate normally I've had it checked out and everyone says it's fine they have all said some make noise and some don't. My tranny is stock 5 speed and my rear end is stock. I've put 12k on it since I bought it and it has never given me a problem.

GL on it hopefully it won't be given you any problems