New wheels ordered!!

You definitely do not want to go with a smaller profile out back. I know a lot of people do it to keep as close to stock height as possible. But if you have a tuner, you can fix the ratio with that. Either way, you want to get the same profile out back as front. A lot of people don't notice it, but the second I see a picture, I can tell if they have a small profile out back. And it looks awful once you start noticing it.