Water Pump - Standard or high volume?

Mike92GT

Founding Member
Jan 23, 2002
583
0
0
Florida
Anyone using a high volume water pump? If so, did you notice any difference in temperature, or any other changes? I live in FL, and while sitting in traffic in the heat, my car's temp will start creeping up. It doesn't go much past 200-210, but I'd like to keep it a tad lower if possible. I'm already using a Mr Gasket 180 t-stat and a big aluminum radiator, I just figured a high volume pump might help. Other mods are in my sig. Thanks
 
I use Stewart High Flow Water Pumps with excellent results....noticable difference.

If the temp is increasing while you are sitting still you need a larger fan and water pump to help cool it while you are not forcing air through the rad.

Are you using a stock fan clutch assembly or a electric set-up
 
yes, I'm using the stock clutch fan ( new clutch) right now. I didn't want to do an electric fan at the time because I didn't want to have to upgrade my alternator. Plus there doesn't seem to be a good electric fan set-up that doesn't require fabrication, and will still clear the 8 rib Vortech crank pulley. I'm not familiar with the Stewart water pumps, I'll have to look them up. I was thinking of maybe getting an Edelbrock...
 
I am with Michael on the fan being more likely. As an aside, we assume you dont have U/D's. Have you considered running an O/D water pump pulley?

Now that asked, I am not sure that the O/D pulley would be wise if you let that nice motor sing for very long.......

Good luck.
 
I actually had u/d pulleys on the car befroe the S-trim install, along with a flex fan, and it ran nice and cool all the time. When I put the blower on, I had to go back to the stock pulleys and fan. I think adding the blower added a lot of underhood temp, plus more power usually requires more to cool it all down. I was actually considering going with a new Vortech underdrive crank pulley with the 4.75 accessory pulley instead of the stock 6.0 inch. I guess this might be counterproductive to my cooling issue, but that clutch fan sure does howl with the stock pulleys
 
Mike, FWIW, I noticed a slight increase in cooling (and noise) at idle with the addition of a metal replacement fan, in lieu of the plastic stocker.
 
Yeah, I was hoping to keep my Flex-fan, but it wouldn't clear the Vortech crank pulley. Just one of many snags that I ran into. Would switching from the stock fan clutch to the HD clutch help a little? I didn't want to go with the H/D clutch originally because I figured it would use more h.p., plus it costs twice as much
 
HISSIN50 said:
Mike, FWIW, I noticed a slight increase in cooling (and noise) at idle with the addition of a metal replacement fan, in lieu of the plastic stocker.


what kinda fans work? and do you need a spacer? i hate electric fans cause i had a couple die on me in other cars (i know the electrics are better but thats the way i am), plus it doesnt get to hot here anyway.
 
88_GT_5_oh said:
what kinda fans work? and do you need a spacer? i hate electric fans cause i had a couple die on me in other cars (i know the electrics are better but thats the way i am), plus it doesnt get to hot here anyway.
The fan blade I used was a direct replacement. IIRC, this is the one I got (I got mine from PAW, but same difference).

Mike, I hear ya on the additional parasitic loss from a HD clutch. Kind of one of those things..... (it is hard to have a great flowing mech fan that does not sap some power; they tend to go hand-in-hand).

I have only used the HD clutch (I live in the desert) so I cant offer a comparison. Some guys really like the SSP fan clutch - again no experience (just tossing out alternatives).

Good luck!
 
I have the SSP fan clutch, it doesn't help me. It also doesn't work with my DCCONTROL FK35! Well, okay, my Taurus fan toasted, and I had to the the stock fan back on until I get a Lincoln fan.

Back to the SSP fan clutch, I have it now, and the MR Gasket Thermo (Thermo helped), but I still creep up in traffic (Sometimes to 230!). I have a Steed Hi Swirl Rad too. Not sure how good it is. It pretty new still, but it never impressed me.

I have found moving air to be the best fix, as mentioned.
 
Another question towards this thread:

So a highflow water pump would help cooling speeds in low mph traffic or at a stop better than a standard? So at idle the car would do better right? Any side effects with a high flow pump? Slightly more power to turn (less engine power)?
 
David - water flow in the system is limited by the t'stat. At low engine speeds, I don't think a high flow pump is gonna change anything at all. A standard or a high flow pump is gonna move MORE than enough water to keep the engine cool -- especially at low engine speeds. While the high flow pump may be capable of moving more -- the additional water it CAN move is likely just gonna be forced through the pump bypass -- which results in just what you've identified - consuming more power without actually moving more water through the engine.

High flow pumps may be needed for engines putting out a LOT more power than stock and the heat that goes with that in the higher rpm ranges.

If you're having a low speed overheating issue -- look elsewhere for the solution. It's VERY doubtful it has anything to do with the water pump. If your pump isn't leaking -- then the odds are very high that it's working just fine.
 
HISSIN50 said:
The fan blade I used was a direct replacement. IIRC, this is the one I got (I got mine from PAW, but same difference).


thanks, i didn't know they even made metal ones for our cars


Michael Yount said:
88 - just where is frozen tundra hell?

winnipeg MB :)


daytime highs of -15C to -20C right now..... give it a month and it will be -30C in the day for a couple of weeks
 
I think I may be experiencing something similar with my Milidon High volume waterpump... I got a Griffin radiator, Viper fan, a DC controler(FC-35) , be cool 180 thermostat and judging from my autometer gauge... the temp slowly goes up to 195(but no higher) without manually turning the fan on full. Driving, even slowly, the temp quicly drops under 180(lowered the temp of the sensor on the DC controler) which could possibly point to RPM based. Granted I do have UD pullies and unfortunately don't have the originals which also doesn't help the situation I am aware of... I never considered that the high volume waterpump could, though unlikely, be part of cause. My thermostat is obviously being overwhelmed and I have also tried a MR Gasket without a difference. I am definately not pushing the power that a supercharger is and I have a pretty common setup. I definately don't live in a frozen tundra hell here in the bay area. I'm subscribing because I am curious too.
Kevin