I would say a 275/40-18 is too wide for the 8.5" wheel. That is the size tire they run on the 10" Roush wheels. I have a 255/45-18 on my 8.5" wheel and it is perfect. You may be able to get a 265 safely on there if it's not too low of a profile tire. 275 on the 8.5" would work if it's short time use like at the drag strip, but I wouldn't recommend it for daily driving that sees various cornering speeds as it could cause unwanted side wall movement under load. .8.5"=215mm so the 275=10.8". That will be 1.4" of sidewall bulge on each side of the wheel.I don't have nearly that much sidewall bulge with the 285/50 on my 10" wheel and that looks like enough.